Metallica VS Megadeth

Originally posted by loserib
Megadeth Smashes all over Nutallica they have way better song compistions and Dave does not sound like a Cuntry singer
play metallicas 4 horseman and megadeths Mechanics and you can hear who is better

is the same song and it was written by Dave

i know its the same song and its the perfect example of why megadeth smashes all over metallica listen to them back to back and you can tell what bands has the better musicains

Nobody "smashes" all over Metallica at their best, lets not get in the deep end without a lifering here.

James Hetfield is the greatest rhythm guitarist ever. Kirk is by far the better lead than Dave. I don't see where you get the idea that Megadeth are better when even Dave admits that they are band number 2 out of the......well the 2.

-AC

greatest rhythm guitarrist???

he's solid player but not that great i can tell you

I'd like to see you do any better 😐

"he's solid player but not that great i can tell you"

....And I can tell you that he is, and we can go round and round, and then I can say Master of Puppets riff, Disposable Heroes riffs, Orion riffs, every riff off Master of Puppets. Not to mention others.

-AC

that doesnt make any sense , i've never said i'm a better ...Hetfield's one of my favorite rhythm guitarrist , but the greatest??

In my opinion, he is the greatest RHYTHM guitarist.

-AC

now that's different ... in YOUR opinion

Well if you compare him to others, nobody can come up with better rhythmical riffs.

-AC

i have to admit that during the 80's he was untouchable , but now he doesnt convince me

Yeah but over time, is what I'm saying.

Any rhythm riffage off Master of Puppets has remain untouchable IMO.

-AC

[edit]

Mustaine is probably more technically skilled than Hammett, but that's not much of a factor.

Mustaine has spent his career trying to escape the shadow of Metallica, so that about sums it up for me.

Mustaine is possibly the greatest rhythem player ever. Try to play his riffs, then try Hetfields. Mustaines are way harder.

Doesn't matter what's harder. It's what's better.

Hetfield put out more better rhythm riffs on Master of Puppets than Megadeth's entire catalogue.

-AC

Originally posted by Alpha Centauri
Yeah but over time, is what I'm saying.

Any rhythm riffage off Master of Puppets has remain untouchable IMO.

-AC

Have to say i agree.

its just my opinion that megadeth smashes all over metallca and im even a fan of old school metallica i just like megadeth better and think they have also been more solid in their music over the years

Master of Puppets Vs Anything Megadeth have ever done, ever.

Metallica win.

Throw in the other legendary stuff they've put out and I believe it's academic.

Dave Mustaine ranks Megadeth as band number 2 out of the two.

-AC

i still rank them higher then metallica