Originally posted by sbo
The secret Wars also had Spidey sneaking up on professor X without being detected until he was right on top of them, which would be impossible. And hulk being crippled by a single laser blast to the leg. They're not a good reference for anything.
Coming from someone who thinks Contest of Champions is completely canon and referable, I'd say we shouldn't go there for your sake. You're a hypocrite.
Rogue isn't beating him.
-AC
Originally posted by Alpha Centauri
Coming from someone who thinks Contest of Champions is completely canon and referable, I'd say we shouldn't go there for your sake. You're a hypocrite.Rogue isn't beating him.
-AC
You're the hypocrite. You said crossovers in general aren't canon and then you bring up secret wars when it suits your purpose.
I'm bringing up inconsistencies within a storyline, not bashing all crossovers in general.
And as I said even without references, Rogue's got too many advantages. She wins.
Oh dear...
*Points to chalkboard*
Cross-over. A term used when two companies in comics, cross rosters and make a dual comic. Such as DC Vs Marvel.
Secret Wars isn't a crossover junior. It was a mini series. Like Infinity Gauntlet or The End.
Inconsistencies within a storyline? X-Men is just about the most inconsistent comic in Marvel history.
Anyway, I'm not about stealing other peoples posting techniques so I'll let you keep yours and I'll get back on topic.
Rogue's got too many advantages? Spider-Man stopped Juggernaut, he's beat the X-Men.
I'd say he wins. Sorry.
-AC
Originally posted by sbo
If you look at the powers that both of them have, Spidey just hasn't got the goods.
......... 😛
Originally posted by Scoobless
just look at the powers she says...........hahahahaha........... that must be why Captain America died that time he fought Scor..... no..... Rhin......hmm, not him either.......must've been Ultr.....waitaminute...Cap's not dead!........ you are being very naive to think looking at a strength chart determines the winner of any fight
Originally posted by sbo
If you actually think that spiderman beating entire X-men team is a realistic event, then you've got some serious brain damage.
he didn't "beat" them, just surprised them, knocked a couple of them around then ran away to tell Cap and Mr F that they were planning to join Magneto (secret wars)....... but they weren't able to stop him from doing it, only Xavier could......... he just made him forget what he had overheard
Originally posted by sbo
If you actually think that spiderman beating entire X-men team is a realistic event, then you've got some serious brain damage.Rogue could tear Spidey's head off and chunk it through aunt May's living room window without any help whatsoever.
While we're talking of "realistic events" in comics I suggest you rethink your position. I know your idea of "realistic" only applies when Rogue wins.
Such a hypocrite.
Rogue has the strength, never doubted that. Spider-Man has alot more. The reason he survives against his enemies is coz he is more skillful, smarter and a better fighter than they are.
Like he is to Rogue.
-AC
Why should I rethink my poosition. I've shown that your reference doesn't hold water, and since you have no counter to my argument, you start whining about things I've said on completely different threads. You're as outmatched on this thread as your good buddy Spidey.
Face it, there's no way that someone with a slight edge in reflexes could beat someone with all of these other powers at their disposal. Agility can only help so much when you're going up against an opponent who is so much faster, stronger, can take anything you can dish out, can come at you from any direction, and can knock you out with no problem at all. Spiderman's good, but not good enough to overcome so much.
Originally posted by sbo
Face it, there's no way that someone with a slight edge in reflexes could beat someone with all of these other powers at their disposal.
Spider-Man is much faster than Rogue, has superior reflexes, is by far a better fighter, has much more experience than Rogue ever will have, is smarter, has a web she just can't break and certainly has the raw power to knock her lights out .
And I even forgot to mention his spider-sense, which will warn him of ANY attack of Rogue.
Rogue only wins if she can grab him. And that's a whole lot easier said than done. Faster, stronger and better people than Rogue have tried it a million times. Lots of his enemies are stronger and more durable, and are way more dangerous than Rogue.
Most of times, he beats them senseless.