What if Qui-Gon didn't die?

There are two types of jedi:-
Rule following- Obi1, Yoda
Rule breaking- Dooku, Qui Gon, Anakin

both anakin and dooku were trained by rule followers, which led them to the dark side. Qui Gon was trained by another rule breaker, so he did not turn.

Well QuiGon didnt want to be on the Jedi council, im not sure why??

Go read Jedi Apprentice, they are really easy to read and short. Obi-wan was a lot like Anakin when he was younger. Anakin would've turned out fine if he had been with Qui-gon.

I am with darth subjekt qui-gon was never a sith and if he were the it would have been revealed and he did die he just found a way to come back spiritualy like at return of the jedi aniken and yoda and obi wan are standing there thats what he figured out how to do

If Qui-Gon didn't die, then he would of killed Tyrannus in AotC. Anikin wouldn't of ever become Darth Vader but Palpatine still might of made the empire.....................some how.

I have to back up your friends ideas.

If Qui Gon didnt die, he would have failed in training Anakin aswell. Anakin is a nutcase. Wah wah! i had a dream about my wife dieing so now im going to kill countless numbers of people, including younglings. Oops I accidentally killed her! Oh well, lets go create an evil empire and kill more people for no good reason.

there are so many things that would have to be factored in from the time qui gon died to when anakin became vader that it isnt possible to conclude what anakin would have become.

I would imagine that Anakin would never have fallen. Qui-Gon was more flexible, and more experianced than Kenobi, who truth be told, did more against the republic then for it.

what if anakin was gay?

what if palpatine was a peace loving hippie?

what if luke accidentally stabbed ben in the face when he first ignighted his fathers lightsaber (he came damn close)

what if jabba DID have his way with leia? what would their offspring look like?

what if jarjar was actually luke and leia's father?

what if? what if? what if?

For heaven' s sake if you don't like the thread then don't post.

"What if" threads are stupid.

Originally posted by Gryn Jabar
For heaven' s sake if you don't like the thread then don't post.

who said i didnt like it?
im just curious of all possible "what if's" and dont feel like cluttering the forum.
and if my post was so useless, how is your response any more useful to the topic? 🙄

Originally posted by PVS
who said i didnt like it?
im just curious of all possible "what if's" and dont feel like cluttering the forum.
and if my post was so useless, how is your response any more useful to the topic? 🙄

What If... George W. Bush bit Lady Liberty??? 😉

Come to think of it Qui-Gon didnt actually "die"

All the movies would be alot better IMO. I loved Qui-Gon.

qui-gon did die, but he didnt disapper because he wasnt very faithful on the teachings of a jedi.

Originally posted by Rockon
qui-gon did die, but he didnt disapper because he wasnt very faithful on the teachings of a jedi.

WTF are you talking about?..... 🤨 I'm confussed

Qui-Gon was one the most respected Jedis. How was he not "faithful"?

He didnt actually die, he went to the other part of the force, same with Obi-Won in Ep.IV.

Was Obi-Wan not faithful?

Watch Ep.III again and listen to Yoda talking to Obi-Wan at the end of the movie. Bcuz Yoda tells Obi-Wan that he has special training for him.

then why didnt Qui-Gon diseapper like Obi-wan and Yoda did. answer that for me.

Qui Gon wasn't faithful to the Jedi teachings... which is why he was able to retain his identity.

The Jedi were wrong, Qui Gon was right.