This argument has been battled over recently, especially me putting a great effort argument on the powers of ESB and ROTJ Luke. ESB Luke is just a bit lesser than Qui-Gon, and Maul comfortably killed Jinn, therefore (not trying to make ABC argument here) Maul would more or less own Luke unfortunately.
As for ROTJ, I would say Luke would be much harder of a fight and it would a lot more closer.
Well we had a thread on this and I argued my a&& off for ESB Luke, saying he won't get owned and that it'll be close. In terms of the argument, I believe I won, because I gave a much better argument than what Sexist and others believed. But yes, if you think aboubt, and consider Luke's current stage as a supreme godlike Force user, then yes, he probably he could QGJ a good run for his money back at his ESB stage.
Wow, Crado, how pathetic! Honestly think I would lie.....here's the link, and you see kamikz's post there:
Darth Maul utterly demolishes Luke. I really don't see Luke giving Maul a decent fight, at all actually, considering the apparent ease of which he tooled Qui-Gon, who was fighting with a "ferocity not seen before" and using a "fresh reserve of strength". Even without considering that, it's obvious Maul is, by far, the better warrior, and Force user.
Originally posted by The Planet
Lying now, are we?
All I saw 'was He had found a fresh reserve of strength during his meditation, and now he was attacking with a ferocity that seemed to have the Sith Lord stymied.'.
Look, Nebaris, if you are going to continue to sock, I suggest you do not blindly assume things, and quit being so rude. Assume things such as that because it wasn't in the novel "word for word", that it is not mentioned anywhere else.
All you saw was that? Well, I see the script:
"When the wall between QUI-GON and DARTH MAUL opens, QUI-GON is in a split second fighting the DARK LORD with a ferocity not seen before."
In addition, that line of the script corresponds with the novel's when referencing "ferocity", as it does state "he was attacking with a ferocity that seemed to have the Sith Lord stymied", so I wouldn't be so quick to dismiss the script in this case.
And me lie? Yes, Nebaris, because my credibility has ever been contested. Puh-leaze. There's really no need to humor me at this point.
I will make mention though, that we all know your credibility has been shot to shit, as you've lied about, or rather, misrepresented Crado's power/status (in the Ultimate Survival thread), lied about your identity, and continue to do such when asked if you're a sock. And the sock ordeal has been ongoing; about six times now? Seven even? Wait, let's count.
If I recall, aren't you supposedly:
1. Count Kent (I know you were; and as Kent, you lied numerous times, making up sources).
2. l0rd?.
3. Blax XXX.
4. Kas'im.
5. Dessel.
6. The Planet.
7. *DoucheFace (seriously; same location, same setup, joined after you were last banned - may be coincidence).
8. Crado.
Nice, long list of socks; although, I may be missing one. But hey, on the bright side of things, you can contend with Numan for number of socks on the SWVF.