Regarding Balance & the death of Palpatine & Vader

Originally posted by Uber_God
um can you name any movies where the main character isnt or doesnt appears to be human?

Enemy Mine? Hitchiker's Guide?

Originally posted by Jedi Priestess
Wait a sec, I may have misunderstood what you meant about Luke using the dark side. What instance are you talking about Uber?

things like how in rotj he chokes those 2 pig guards

Originally posted by bilb
But every single thing I have said was shown ONSCREEN!!

I know that girlfriend, but there isnt a big ole sign that flashes BALANCE RESTORED at the exact moment. Hence this discussion. 😂

Originally posted by Uber_God
things like how in rotj he chokes those 2 pig guards

Thats not evil, he didnt kill them, merely disabled them in the process of a rescue..

Originally posted by bilb
Enemy Mine? Hitchiker's Guide?

fair enough
but the dude from hitchhikers guide did appear to be human

Originally posted by Uber_God
things like how in rotj he chokes those 2 pig guards

Yeah I misread ya, I thought you were talking book wise. My bad. 😮

Originally posted by Jedi Priestess
I know that girlfriend, but there isnt a big ole sign that flashes BALANCE RESTORED at the exact moment. Hence this discussion. 😂

Just playin by your own rules missy!! Just cause I make sense dont mean I'm wrong!!! 😆 😎

Originally posted by bilb
Thats not evil, he didnt kill them, merely disabled them in the process of a rescue..

still the force choke thing is part of the dark side

Originally posted by Jedi Priestess
Yeah I misread ya, I thought you were talking book wise. My bad. 😮

im waiting to see ep3 before i read any eu books 😛

Originally posted by Uber_God
fair enough
but the dude from hitchhikers guide did appear to be human

your eyes can decieve you, dont trust them..............

I never saw that as a force choke myself, but what do I know. And I am making sense Miss Bilb. 😛

Originally posted by bilb
your eyes can decieve you, dont trust them..............

yes master

Originally posted by Uber_God
still the force choke thing is part of the dark side

I think the intent and outcome are as or more important than the act in this case

Originally posted by Uber_God
im waiting to see ep3 before i read any eu books 😛

90% of sux IMHO Uber. 😂

Originally posted by Jedi Priestess
I never saw that as a force choke myself, but what do I know. And I am making sense Miss Bilb. 😛

Really? When? Got a link? 😆 😛

Originally posted by Jedi Priestess
90% of sux IMHO Uber. 😂

pardon?

i understood 90% and uber
but thats about it

Originally posted by Jedi Priestess
90% of sux IMHO Uber. 😂

99%

EDIT : nvm i got it

what exactly are the parts that do not suck according to you two?

Grrrrrrrrrrrrr!! Bilb, you know that I am making perfect sense. My point is this in order to bring balance to the Force Anakin had to destroy the Sith. When Vader (who is back to ANAKIN) tosses Sideous over the railing he has done that. He has fulfilled his desitny and balance is restored at that moment. That was the question. Not whether or not Vader had to die, but at what moment balance was restored. 😛 😛

Originally posted by Uber_God
um shouldnt this be in the IV-VI section?

and i say balance was restored after vader and palpatine died.
Because of how luke used the light and dark sides of the force

Yep, it needs to be moved.

Regardless if it's about Anakin fulfilling his destiny. This is still a discussion about Return of the Jedi.