Regarding Balance & the death of Palpatine & Vader

All I have liked are the books that cover the movies themselves, a few in between, Shadows of the Empire and the Thrawn trilogy..

Originally posted by Lan©eWindu™
Yep, it needs to be moved.

Regardless if it's about Anakin fulfilling his destiny. This is still a discussion about Return of the Jedi.

Thats peachy, if you were knighted you could do that for us. 🙂 And whats your opinion here Lance?

Originally posted by Jedi Priestess
Grrrrrrrrrrrrr!! Bilb, you know that I am making perfect sense. My point is this in order to bring balance to the Force Anakin had to destroy the Sith. When Vader (who is back to ANAKIN) tosses Sideous over the railing he has done that. He has fulfilled his desitny and balance is restored at that moment. That was the question. Not whether or not Vader had to die, but at what moment balance was restored. 😛 😛

Damnit woman!! LISTEN TO ME... POTENTIAL to turn back. POTENTIAL is the key word. When he dies, yes absolutely he has been redeemed but he is still human and still capable of making mistakes!!

And Uber, Clone Wars and LOE are great IMO...............

Originally posted by Jedi Priestess
Grrrrrrrrrrrrr!! Bilb, you know that I am making perfect sense. My point is this in order to bring balance to the Force Anakin had to destroy the Sith. When Vader (who is back to ANAKIN) tosses Sideous over the railing he has done that. He has fulfilled his desitny and balance is restored at that moment. That was the question. Not whether or not Vader had to die, but at what moment balance was restored. 😛 😛

maybe by killing himself and the emperor is how he brought balance

Originally posted by Jedi Priestess
Ok so Bilb and I were debating this. I think that by Vader tossing Palpatine down the shaft in ROTJ balance was restored at that moment.

Bilb however feels differently, she thinks that balance was not restored until both Palpatine AND Vader are died.

What do you think and why?

The question is WHEN IS BALANCE RESTORED???

NOT does Anakin have to die. 😛

Balance is restored once BOTH are dead...

Originally posted by Jedi Priestess
But who's to say he'd be using the dark side of the force had he lived?

Originally posted by Uber_God
um shouldnt this be in the IV-VI section?

and i say balance was restored after vader and palpatine died.
Because of how luke used the light and dark sides of the force

ok now look at the sentence I circled Bilb. You plainly state that when Sideous is killed balance is achieved. Then you go on to add why Anakin must die, so that it stays in balance. But its Sideous death that brings the balance. See what I mean?

Yes and then look at the VERY NEXT SENTENCE as well..

Let me guess, you only read one select passage from the whole of the Bible as well? 😛

where does it say about why vader must die?

Originally posted by bilb
Yes and then look at the VERY NEXT SENTENCE as well..

Let me guess, you only read one select passage from the whole of the Bible as well? 😛

i did
its in my sig aswell 😛

She was talking to me Uber.

Originally posted by Jedi Priestess
ok now look at the sentence I circled Bilb. You plainly state that when Sideous is killed balance is achieved. Then you go on to add why Anakin must die, so that it stays in balance. But its Sideous death that brings the balance. See what I mean?

OK miss imma quote yer ass............. I DID type that and i WAS WRONG!! Like i have said many times, HUMANS MAKE MISTAKES. My point has been for four pages now that it takes the death of both for balance to be restored..

Originally posted by Jedi Priestess
She was talking to me Uber.

i know
i was just pointing it out

and bilb has a point

Originally posted by Uber_God
where does it say about why vader must die?

The word Potential , Uber..

k

Originally posted by bilb
OK miss imma quote yer ass............. I DID type that and i WAS WRONG!! Like i have said many times, HUMANS MAKE MISTAKES. My point has been for four pages now that it takes the death of both for balance to be restored..

Kimmers eyes

Originally posted by Jedi Priestess
Kimmers eyes

Back atcha!! 😊

so is this discussion at an end?
who won?
was it me?