who directed episode II?

Started by queeq4 pages

The Hoth battle didn't change in the SE, they only cleaned it up and removed the matte lines which technology couldn't remove properly in those days.

I know, but as far as the action goes, it's pretty lame. They can completely go back and put more troops and more vehicles in and redo that entire sequence and make it more dramatic. Just keep the luke parts the same but have more going on elsewhere. I think that and the Endor battle have to be redone. They have to add more Ewoks and Stormtroopers to that battle. We have to assume that there are thousands of Ewoks to be able to defeat teh Imperial Army. The Rancor scene must be redone, and maybe more of what Fett is doing during the Skiff battle. The saber effects have to be redone....wait the list is too long, but when they do it these movies are going to be finally complete and we will all be the happiest people on Earth.

Just adding more attack vehicles, planes, men and creatures doesn't make it a great action sequence. The Hoth ground attack was very well devised and the way it was storyboarded, shot and directed make it a good action sequence.... the feel, the pace, stuff like that. Not numbers.
And then there was the awesome Asteriod field chase...

The Hoth battle is the best battle of the movies. It really doesn't matter how much people there are like queeq said. Hoth battle is much more interesting than the battle of Naboo.

You're crazy.

I know.

But also right.

So Helmet doesn't agree with battle of Hoth beeing better than battle of Naboo? 🙄 😕

I guess...

The Naboo battle was much better. Maybe not after they fix it.

Maybe showing more of Vader during his journey into the rebel base. Doing some saber work.

Better?! 😱

Hoth better, more don't need to know

🙂

You can't tell me that the rebels couldn't defeat the Imperial Walkers, but they have the ability to destroy a Death Star. Come on, that's weak. Sowing more imperial Snowtroopers marching down with some other walkers, along with the AT-AT's would make the retreat so much more believable. Add some more rebel fighters into the battle, as well as soldiers. It would be so much better.

The battle of Naboo was ruined by Jar Jar.

Oh... believable..... a nine year old lwing up a space ship no one else could.... that's believable. 🙄

Jar Jar didn't ruin anything.

Hoth was just classic

Originally posted by queeq
Oh... believable..... a nine year old lwing up a space ship no one else could.... that's believable. 🙄

That just shows how little you understand. If that 9 year old boy is the chosen one yes. If that boy has the ability to be the only human pod racer in the universe, yes. If that boy can build anything and understand flying like he does, yes!. Any more questions?

Jar Jar didn't ruin the movie, but he definetly ruined the Naboo battle. Along with Anakin. The whole battle of Naboo doesn't feel like it's anything serious. It's pure humor.