nope he came abck from the dead in many diffrent realility and his own. he had his heart stop on many occassions. back when his healing factor was not even that good he came back from the dead to save jean greys life. in wolverine 32 he had his head cut of on mnay occassions and was ifne the next day. he had his whole skseleton ripped out and he healed form that. he been incenagrated. he been hit with a nuke. I cna keep going on. having his heart ripped out would not kill him.
again, i'll point out that losing an organ is very different than having an organ simply malfunction. if you'll kindly point out where he's come back from the dead, and maybe tidy up your speech patterns (his head cut off on many occasions in the same issue?) i'll consider your argument. his skeleton itself was not ripped out, simply the adamantium was ripped off his bones. and it was one of the most traumatic experiences of his superheroing career and maimed his ability to heal himself for some time.
my point is not to argue that having his heart ripped out would kill him, though it may send him into a horrible state of shock. i'm simply arguing that he's not a post-mortem regenerate, as you're implying, and instances of "coming back from the dead" should be re-evaluated, as he was likely not "dead" to begin with.
"megneto may have sucked out my adamantium but you pulled out my whole skeleton once".(x-men unlimited bloodscream the heart of darkness). yes he ahs had his whole skeleton ripped out. wolverine had his head cut off many tiems in a death camp in world war 2( wolverine 32). when megneto ripped out his adamatium it said he cmae back from the dead. also I pritty sure having ur brain and heart stop on many occassions would make u quite dead ecpt for the fact that his cells are still veyr much a life.
legally dead =/= dead. death occurs when your body runs entirely out of useful resources, often propogated by the stilling of organs such as the heart or brain, and your body begins to atrophy. that takes quite a bit of time, and regenerating post-mortem is not something a healing factor housed in LIVING cells can cause. sorry, wolverine isn't a post-mortem regenerate, unlike dead girl or mr. immortal. no argument is going to prove otherwise.
and until i can check out the issues you mentioned, i'll reserve judgement
Originally posted by xmarksthespot
It's never shown only stated in a narration - likely a hyperbole to appease fans. Severing the head from the body = death - the brain cannot function without oxygen, the heart does not function without input from the brain.
http://www.comicreaders.com/modules.php?name=News&file=article&sid=1609
from the last paragraph: "We should probably note here that the Nazis never cut off Logan's head, which would have probably killed him"
and "beheadings" is only mentioned in a narrative. never shown, never substantiated, as far as the UXN review tells me. whatever the Nazis thought they were doing, they must've been doing wrong...
and how many times do i need to say it!? having an organ stop working is not the same as not having the organ! people go into cardiac arrest all the time, and live. very few people who go "brain dead" survive, but there are cases. regular people! not superhumans with healing factors! it's not nearly the same!
On panel, he has had his brain - the medulla in particular - disconnected from his body for prolonged periods of time?
On panel, he has had his cardiac function ceased or his heart destroyed - particularly the right ventricle and atrium - for prolonged periods of time?
I can't find the incident you mentioned in X-Men #96 or Uncanny X-Men #96.
Originally posted by Disappear
http://www.comicreaders.com/modules.php?name=News&file=article&sid=1609from the last paragraph: "We should probably note here that the Nazis never cut off Logan's head, which would have probably killed him"
and "beheadings" is only mentioned in a narrative. never shown, never substantiated, as far as the UXN review tells me. whatever the Nazis thought they were doing, they must've been doing wrong...
and how many times do i need to say it!? having an organ stop working is not the same as not having the organ! people go into cardiac arrest all the time, and live. very few people who go "brain dead" survive, but there are cases. regular people! not superhumans with healing factors! it's not nearly the same!
ur piont it was still stated that they cut of his head. the man who cut off his head stated this so it does not change the fact that his head was cut the **** off.
nor can i find it in x-men 96-100, or uncanny x-men 96-100.
quicksilver claimed joseph was magneto. changeling claimed he was professor x. hell, gambit and wolverine have even masqueraded as cyclops and the beast. was joseph magneto? was changeling xavier? were gambit and logan really scott and hank? things said do not equal things done. i can continue to cite examples if you'd like, though this last one should clinch it. the commandant of the camp said logan was dead. he said he and his men killed logan more than once. where's the hard evidence that his word is truth?
Originally posted by xmarksthespot
On panel, he has had his brain - the medulla in particular - disconnected from his body for prolonged periods of time?
On panel, he has had his cardiac function ceased or his heart destroyed - particularly the right ventricle and atrium - for prolonged periods of time?I can't find the incident you mentioned in X-Men #96 or Uncanny X-Men #96.