Darth Bandon vs Darth Maul

Who would win in a battle of the apprentices?

Before you say that Bandon was so weak in the game, yes he was, but remember that we play from the position of Revan. Sort of messes up the view of him.
But Malak chose him over thousands of other sith, and he would have chosen the strongest out of the bunch. If there was a stronger sith out there, he would have killed Bandon and taken his place.
Also, it says in many places that Bandon duelled many jedi, and they all fell before him. It also said that he had yet to meet his match in combat. And being the apprentice of the dark lord, you would meet some powerful opponents.

Personally I think that Bandon is underestimated here, but I might be wrong. Anyway, please respond.

I think that, while very talented and badass, Maul is outclassed here. Bandon was no doubt a Jedi of prowess who fought in the Mandalorian Wars before working his way up the ranks of hundreds of Sith warriors. That in itself speaks measures.

yes I agree

Bandon would win.

Give me a break.

ok jack, we know that you like Maul, but please give us some reasons for him winning, I'll admit in the movie and in Darth Maul: Shadow Hunter, he was amazing, but in shadow hunter he faces off against weak opponents, actually wait, he did duel a jedi master, whatever. And in TPM he should have won, but thats not very tough opponents. A 70 year old man and a 20 year old kid. Any ancient sith lord could have done that. I have yet to see any proof that he could stand against the ancients and win. If you give me proof, I will re-think my position, but for now, I will think of him as a powerful sith, but not able to kill much more than a knight or weak master.

Nicely put.

I say maul... although bandon outclassed so many sith and was taught by malak... I would still say maul because he was taught by Sidious who taught yoda a thing or two in their duel. I dont think there is many force users who can do that. So he must of chose maul for something. Also bandon would look at maul and think he was the devil himself.

Only if maul is overconfident he would lose... Obi-wan that cheap shot.

Malak is a weakling... While fighting Revan had to extract power from jedi just to keep on fighting... There's not much he can teach bandon but to be a wussy.

Bah. Nonsense. Malak was a frontline Jedi general in the Mandalorian Wars. Sidious could teach Maul how to help him wipe and get into hsi throne, the old cripple.

"Come, my dark apprentice. Let me show you powah with the lightsabah! Ack... hack... cough... My lungs... my lungs! Excuse me, son. I'm too old to masturbate without taking a nap. Let's just get a Sith how-to pop up book."

There's your superior mentor. Six years past his AARP card and keeps forgetting why he wants to take over the galaxy anyways.

Malak is a dumba$$... frontline jedi my a$$. Wow shows how much the jedi know... He could take a shit right next to yoda and he would not know the evil leaving his body...

Malak is better than you give him credit for. Don't make me smite you via pictures.

Your right... Revan is a dumba$$ for not knowing that Malak would betray him...

This is off-topic, so read only if you're bored.

Y'know, I see a lot of Padawan Obi-Wan giving Maul a 'cheat shot', but in a sense, isn't Obi-Wan only doing what his/Qui-Gon/Yoda's style says he should do? Form IV lightsaber combat calls for Force-assisted acrobatics and athletic manuevers in order to either find an opening or catch your opponent off guard and cut them down. Perfectly viable, and thus there was no cheap shot. Maul just made a mistake in not finishing the young Padawan when he had the chance.

Come to think of it, if anyone had a cheap shot, it was Maul Force-pushing Obi-Wan over the shaft's lip when he started getting pressed.

Yeah, instead of saying Obi Wan was a cheap shot or calling Revan and Malak dumbasses, why not call Maul on his own idiocy?

Oh I know it's just a stupid way to die... Anyway maul gets my vote.

Bah. We have no tempted this one enough. Here is my final offer...

Dark side I must not fall... Must not join... Must resist...

Join us! We get free parking and 401K!