Rogue vs. Thor

Enlighten this poor padawan...

Originally posted by sbo
She knocked Thor out, so he didn't win that fight did he?
Even without the element of surprise, all she needs is to get close and thor's out.

I have a migraine. I can't argue.

bump

Thor was probably distracted by her beauty and was knocked out. Or very bad writing. Thor on any day of the week will make Rogue one of his handmaidens. Battle wise, Thor will knock Rogue out in one punch. Did that really happen? Did Rogue really knock Thor out?

What's a padawan?

And yes, Rogue did knock out Thor.

Originally posted by Sentry
Thor was probably distracted by her beauty and was knocked out. Or very bad writing. Thor on any day of the week will make Rogue one of his handmaidens. Battle wise, Thor will knock Rogue out in one punch. Did that really happen? Did Rogue really knock Thor out?

Yes. In Rogue's first appearance. Thor thought she was just a normal teenage girl and tried to reason with her. But Rogue kissed him and absorbed his powers.

I don't think so. During Onslaught saga the avengers found magneto(clone) with rogue and they wanted to bring him and rogue was trying to defind him she socked thor in the process, but he hasn't even faded looked at her with a look like that was it.

Rogue will get murder she is no matched for a god let alone a warrior god. One good hit from his fists or hammer she will be in a coma for awhile.

Originally posted by the Darkone
I don't think so. During Onslaught saga the avengers found magneto(clone) with rogue and they wanted to bring him and rogue was trying to defind him she socked thor in the process, but he hasn't even faded looked at her with a look like that was it.

That wasn't the encounter that i was referring to. In their first encounter she touched his face and knocked him out instantly.

For the last time, Thor didn't know Rogue from Eve. She was an 18-year old girl wearing a green hood. How the hell was Thor supposed to know that a single touch would drain his powers?

You're missing my point here, he's let her get close enough to absorb his powers since that first time. So he obviously hasn't learned his lesson.

You're deluding yourself. Rogue was hysterical about Joseph. Not to mention it wasn't a fight. Merely an arguement. He knew Rogue wasn't stupid enough to try and absorb him; especially considering the state of her mind at the time. (i.e. Gambit).

Like I said, tricked by her beauty. Thor wins. One blast from the Mjlonir would take her out without even touching her.

She was little girl. He took pity on her. He wasn't gonna wack a teenage girl with a hammer that hurts the Hulk.

That's why Thor's going to lose again, he's obviously too strong for her physically and he knows it, his hesitation to strike is what will cause his defeat again.

???? That's bull****

He won't hestiate. He hit the friggin Enchantress through a castle.

Rogue was a teenage girl he didn't know and was probably troubled. Thor won't hestitate this time. Especially since this bloodlust.

You're grasping straws. Or air more accurately.

no, Rogue is stronger than people think. In the 90's cartoon she went toe-to-toe with gladiator for about 3 minutes in the "the fate of the phoenix". So if she can last 3 minutes with Glad's, i'd say she could maybe last 5 against Thor.

And in the X-Men movie she didn't have ANY powers at all. Don't use media items as evidence. Would you want someone stupid enough to quote the Thing from the upcoming Fantastic Four movie has a preindicator of his strength level? No? Good.

And Gladiator defeated her in a comic with a casual slap.

Originally posted by Draco69
???? That's bull****

He won't hestiate. He hit the friggin Enchantress through a castle.

Rogue was a teenage girl he didn't know and was probably troubled. Thor won't hestitate this time. Especially since this bloodlust.

You're grasping straws. Or air more accurately.

You never said this fight was a bloodlust battle, if that's what you meant you should have stated it at the beginning of the thread.

If it were a bloodlust battle thor would win easily, he'd hit her with everything he had when he first saw her.

Originally posted by armandovalles
no, Rogue is stronger than people think. In the 90's cartoon she went toe-to-toe with gladiator for about 3 minutes in the "the fate of the phoenix". So if she can last 3 minutes with Glad's, i'd say she could maybe last 5 against Thor.

where not talking about cartoons. Thor is to damn strong for here and powerful and he is alot faster then she is. Rogue is strong but she's not that strong to take on a god for godsakes, the fight will not last that long she will be lucky if she wakes up from coma that thor will put her in.