Rogue vs. Thor

I had to comic this.

The most accurate comic to date.

If it were a bloodlust battle it would be accurate, but for this thread it's not. Thor wouldn't kill someone at first sight.

????

Thor has been killing things since he was 16 years old. You're obviously completely ignorant about Thor.

Well then why didn't he just kill Rogue in his first encounter with her, or in his second encounter?

1st encounter: He's not gonna kill a 18 year old girl that he presumed to be human. That would be overkill.

2nd encounter: He's not gonna kill Rogue in front of Captain America and the X-Men. They'll never forgive him.

Originally posted by sbo
If it were a bloodlust battle it would be accurate, but for this thread it's not. Thor wouldn't kill someone at first sight.

The rules of this forum specifically state "bloodlust" which means they will give it their all.

And you're lucky nobody hasn't mentioned King Thor...

The rules state that each opponent will fight within their personality. Bloodlust isn't within rogue or thor's personality.

Which shows you know NOTHING about Thor. Bloodlust isn't Thor's personality? That's like saying Wolverine is a virgin. Hah! You're hysterical. 😂

To the best of their abilities while staying in character. Unfortunately that means some will kill and some won't.

I'll ask you again, since you ignored the question the last time, if thor is so bloodthirsty, why didn't he just kill rogue in the first place. He's obviously capable of doing it.

God, you're slow. Teenage girl. 18 years old. No reason to kill. Thor was trying to reason with Rogue. Why the hell would Thor kill a teenage girl in front of all his friggin teammates?

There's obviously no getting through your thick skull with reason, but I'll say it again.
Thor didn't try to kill her the 1st time or the 2nd time , so why would his first reaction be to kill her this time.

Thick skull? You're obviously nigh-insane. You just being stubborn:

AGAIN:

1st encounter: "God, you're slow. Teenage girl. 18 years old. No reason to kill. Thor was trying to reason with Rogue. Why the hell would Thor kill a teenage girl in front of all his friggin teammates?"

2nd encounter: Why the hell would Thor kill Rogue in front of the Avengers and the X-Men? Especially when it was completely unnecessary and they need everyone they could for the battle against Onslaught.

As I said: "Fanboy to the highest order"

Again I ask you how is this encounter any different than the previous 2?

Why would he kill her this time?

You still won't answer this question because you know the answer is, he wouldn't.

sbo, maybe you have the word bloodlust mixed up. In this case, it's not like doomsday-rawr-kill-everything. It's just not beyond Thor to kill something.

And in this fight, he doesn't really even need to. He knows Rogue's power now. He's a warrior. I'm sure he can swat Rogue away without touching her skin. Unless she's coming at him in a bikini or something.

Originally posted by sbo
Again I ask you how is this encounter any different than the previous 2?

Bloodlust specifies that characters stay in character but give it everything they have. Thor has killed thousands of people. Killing isn't beneath him. Rogue is no different. And do you really think Rogue can withstand a GodForce blast? You'll probably say yes...

Originally posted by sbo
Why would he kill her this time?

As I said bloodlust.

Originally posted by sbo
You still won't answer this question because you know the answer is, he wouldn't.

He would. Easily. Thor almost murdered Iron Man. One of his best friends. He killed his own brother. He wouldn't stoop to not killing Rogue.

You need serious clinical help. You're the ONLY person who thinks Rogue would win. Everyone else is just laughing at your audacity.

I don't disagree that he could beat her, but the fact that he hasn't yet leads me to believe that he'd let the same thing happen again. He's let her get his hands on him twice and he still didn't keep out of reach.

And I'm not saying that thor would never kill, but that wouldn't be his first reaction.

If they're staying in character thor won't give it everything he has at the onset of the fight.

You not doubting that Thor can and would beat Rogue....but you don't believe Thor wouldn't actually beat Rogue because he's gonna hold back like a dunce? 🤨