Evangel's Amalgam Tournament: Stormfront13 vs Nataku8188 (Vote Now!)

Started by Nataku818827 pages
Originally posted by stormfront13
and once again surfer can't absord magic. i could create a very powerful magical blast that surfer can't absord and it will damage you

Who says he can't absorb magic? That scan says he can do whatever he wants.

Originally posted by Khellendros
If Scoob and Dael and you can add their thoughts, I can too.

i'm not adding stratagies, i'm just reafirming the rules.... you are adding ideas to the fight that SF never mentioned

thwn why was he beaten before?

Originally posted by Nataku8188
Who says he can't absorb magic? That scan says he can do whatever he wants.

Oh, well if a character SAID they could do anything, that's obviously gospel, meaning he could rape the Living Tribunal.

in every bio i have ever read and everything i have ever seen of surfer ie can't do anything he wants

Originally posted by Khellendros
If Scoob and Dael and you can add their thoughts, I can too.

i'm not... when i voted sf challenged my opinion and i repsonded with one post...

nobody should be helping either debater...

Originally posted by stormfront13
in every bio i have ever read and everything i have ever seen of surfer ie can't do anything he wants

Every comic i have ever read with Zatanna doesn't have her doing whatever she wants.

Originally posted by pr1983
nobody should be helping either debater...

Why not? Evangel never said we couldn't add to the debates...

what excatley is she doing then nataku?

oh any pr you changed your vote? who do you vote for?

Originally posted by Khellendros
Why not? Evangel never said we couldn't add to the debates...

it takes away the point of entering to debate for yourself.... i'm sure the person who wins would rather do it on their own merit than because someone else did it for them.... it is a game after all

Originally posted by stormfront13
what excatley is she doing then nataku?

Mostly freezing enemies, changing weapons to flamingos, that sort of thing. Whereas if she could do whatever she wanted, she could just make people like Parallax go back to being plain ole' Hal, keep people like Supes from dieing, not do such a shoddy job on Dr. Light's mind wipe.

Zatanna doesn't do whatever she wants because she can't, just like SS can't. They can both do almost anything, but they have their limits.

Originally posted by stormfront13
oh any pr you changed your vote? who do you vote for?

my vote is the same as it was...

i vote for nataku...

no wrong again nataku. zatanna can do whatever she wants. she doesn't because that would be a stupid story. ever wonder why she hardly appers now? because DC realized how powerful she is and now she only make appearances in comics and isn't in anything long-running right now

Originally posted by Khellendros
Why not? Evangel never said we couldn't add to the debates...

True. I think small additions are acceptable, but we shouldn't distract attention from the two main debaters, and just use common sense and our own personal judgement to stay within those limits. People's brief descriptions of why they voted one way or another is a good example.

-DM

EDIT: Okay, I'll stay out of it, since the general consensus is that I'm overstepping my bounds.

k i want to know what excatley surfer will do to me when i am in mist form, surrounded by a force field, and can redirect any blast he throws at me. and if he magages to break the forcefield ii can create a two way potral where the other ope appers right infront of him like not even a centimeter away. then while that is happening create another forcefield arounf myself

Originally posted by stormfront13
no wrong again nataku. zatanna can do whatever she wants. she doesn't because that would be a stupid story. ever wonder why she hardly appers now? because DC realized how powerful she is and now she only make appearances in comics and isn't in anything long-running right now

Or maybe you're just wrong. You talk like DC can't just change her powers. She isn't self-contained, she is whatever DC makes of her, and DC has decided she isn't popular enough to sell comics so she isn't in comics.

Originally posted by stormfront13
k i want to know what excatley surfer will do to me when i am in mist form, surrounded by a force field, and can redirect any blast he throws at me. and if he magages to break the forcefield ii can create a two way potral where the other ope appers right infront of him like not even a centimeter away. then while that is happening create another forcefield arounf myself

All at once too, huh? Especially beacuse the only concrete evidence in this thread shows that Zat has to speak backwards.

If zat can do whatever she wants, but chooses not to, then I'm going with the same logic for Silver Surfer. Especially since he's said that he can. Your logic sucks.

no, she can do anything, so she could eleminate of any opponent and is too powerful, she could easily beat superman. her powers make her able to do anything, and as of yet she hasn't found a limit. you can be weong you know