Gryffindor's Common Room

When you PM'ed me yours and Tigress' theories on Wednesday (my time) I PM'ed a reply saying that it would be good to incorporate both but obviously I don't know what everyone else replied, if at all. As far as I saw and thought though, I was under the impression that it wasn't finished and you were going to polish it off because it wasn't a theory it was just an idea at that stage.

What about the potion? Tassie PM'ed me with the start of one on Tuesday (my time) to ask what I thought etc, I replied and she said she'd work on it the next day, so I figured you'd both be finished with Tasks 1 & 3 by now 😕

As for Task 2, no one actually volunteered to help with that as far as I know but Tigress did fortunately find three answers, but that means we have three left - which ones did she do?

IF it turns out the potion and the theory aren't finished then we need to be penalised because everyone else have great detailed entries; it it's just the questions then I'm sure we can be forgiven because they haven't been posted yet but we need to come up with the answers ASAP.

I did q3,q4,q8

Excellent, I've got the answer to Q7 but I can't find 5 & 6. Anyone else?

good. I will go and polish the theory and submit it TODAY. Promise.

RebelPHoe, I just looked at your message and you did say that I should incoporate what I wrote and what tigree wrote for the theory.
I am SO sorry. It's just that it's been awhile since I read your message, so when you said that above, I was confused.

That's alright Rogue, as long as we can get all of our entries in quick fast and be happy with them that's all that matters 🤓

5 and six argh mu brain needs re booting I'll keep looking.

is it just me or is it possible q6 mught be a trick question i cant find anything on it at all ive combed through ootp because the books go through history mostly in this for the owls. Iam stuck totally sorry I did my best .

I'll take a look at question 6.
I just finished revising the theory and PM'ed them to everyone. Take a look at it.

Theory is perfect.

Thanks. I'll go post it now. in the IH thread that is.

ARGH!!! Omg NO!

You posted it without me getting to reply to your PM! 🙁🙁🙁🙁

I know it wasn't your fault cos it took me like 40minutes to reply - it's just that when I read your theory so much came to mind and I added TONS! Which is why it took so long! 🙁

Oh well... you still posted a great theory 🙂

Sorry RebelPhoe. I should have waited. . .

Anyhow, I'll just go and post it again in the IH thread. Everyone makes mistakes, so I'll just repost it.

WAIT! lol I forgot to add one bit when I PM'ed you earlier 😮

I'll write it in and then post it 🙂

okay. Thanks for the warning cuz I was THIS CLOSe to posting another one.

okay. Thanks for the warning cuz I was THIS CLOSe to posting another one.

I just sent you the one that I combined your info with. Do you think that it may be a bit long?? I kind of condensed it a little.

Yes, I thought so and I'm currently trying to shorten it abit as well - I agree with you cutting out the last part which was totally something new and not brought up but also very speculative.

Ok I have it and I PM'ed you the bit I forgot to put in before. Oh and I remembered to check the spelling and grammar too lol 😮

Good good.
I read it and I loved it. Some of that stuff you wrote I didn't even think about until now. That makes so much more sense.

^Thanks Rogue 🙂

Sooo, where are we now? Or maybe more appropriately, where is Tassie? 🙁 😖 - she had our start for a potion and was going to finish it...

As for Task 2 - Volunteers? Anybody!? We've done 4 out of 6 questions (Ravenclaw's and Hufflepuff's) but we haven't found the answers to Slytherin's questions yet, so if anybody can find them please do! ✅ They are in the Challenge Thread on pg 33.