I think it's possible. I mean, I know I'm nowhere near society's definition of beauty, as Syren told me I'm unusual-looking (she meant it as a compliment ๐). Yet I still think that I look pretty, and apparently other people think so as well, since I get a lot of compliments and people (male and female) telling me that I'm beautiful, I'm hot, I'm sexy....yeah, there are times when I wish that I were a little thinner or something, but for the most part I'm happy with how I look.
I also tend to think that guys who also aren't what society generally thinks of what is good-looking are the hottest, they stand out more to me โ Like, for instance, Hayden's a cutie, but if it were between him or Brandon Boyd, Brandon would win, hands down.