Rate Episode III

Started by DeVi| D0do3 pagesPoll

Poll

Rate Episode III

111 total votes

DeVi| D0do The 8th Deadly Sin

Rate Episode III

10 being perfect, 1 being atrocious

Cheesiness Senior Member

Tsk tsk tsk...

Imaginary blinded

Have you seen it, Cheesiness?

Cheesiness Senior Member
Originally posted by Imaginary
Have you seen it, Cheesiness?

No.

finti Senior Member

gave it a 3

Imaginary blinded

Didn't think so.

Cheesiness Senior Member
Originally posted by Imaginary
Didn't think so.

Why did you think that?

Imaginary blinded
Originally posted by finti
gave it a 3

Why's that, finti?

finti Senior Member

Why's that, finti?
it didnt deserve more. Great effects but the story is really really weak and so is a lot of the acting. Just to compare I gave AOTC 1 and TPM 0, As of the OT ANH 9, ESB 10, ROTJ 6.

To sum it up, GL took too many shortcuts to pressing issues to tie the saga together, he even messes up and make some of the dialogue in the OT complete irrelevant

((The_Anomaly)) 2003 Super Senior Member

i gave it a 9, a little more length would have been better, overall it was amazing!

the sword fights, jebus!!!! i was stunned by the Obi/ Anakin fight, it was simply amazing..

finti Senior Member

another thing the rubber mask of the Emperor was horrible, with all the time spent on effects that was all they bothered to come up with concerning the Emperor.

queeq Chaos

Amen!

EHmasterJedi Jedi Master

Gave it a 8, to anyone else did it seem like GG, Dooku, Mace Windu were killed and Anakin was already turned to the darkside in like the first 10 mintues lol, things happened REAL fast it seamed like.

Imaginary blinded

Yeah, their sabers were literally blue blurs. I thought Palpy's masks were pretty bad, his grunting in the Mace scene just made me go "🤨" Also, some of the dialogue was pretty cheesy, like the Anakin-Padme "I'm in love with you" exchange. And I thought when Anakin said to Obi-Wan "Don't make me kill you" (or something to that extent) it should have been "Don't make me destroy you" just to connect the PT and OT better. The humour was out of place, I think... it was good, I just don't think it belonged in RotS.

My $0.02 🙂

DeVi| D0do The 8th Deadly Sin

I liked Palp's grunting and other... noises. And the faces he makes in that sequence... Ian rocks!

queeq Chaos

Palpy's grunting was terrible.

DeVi| D0do The 8th Deadly Sin

what can I say? I liked it. 😄

and his weird "No, no, no, you will die!"... I LOVED IT!

the masks were horrible though.

Imaginary blinded

✅

queeq Chaos

Yup, I gave it an eight.

Jedi Priestess yeah baby

I gave it an 8, but I really would have given it a 7.5 had that been an option.