Rate Episode III

I think the whole Grievous thing was kinda stupid... they could have cut that whole bit out.

He has no backstory... the coughing, his heart and all that stuff... I know it's been dealt with in books, cartoons etc. but everything we needed to know souhld have been in the film, which it wasn't.

People around me were confused too... 'what the-? droids have hearts?'

i give it an 8 maybe 8.5 i thought it was amazing except for padme and her corny lines ugh *rolls eyes*, and i few other things but this movie def tops TPM and AOTC i thought it was the best of the prequels and almost as good at the OT. i agree that it did seem like things happened fast, i didnt think anakin would side with palpatine untill later in the film. I still dont understand how palpatine just came up w/ the name darth vader, thought there would be an explaination for that.

At this stage the average based on this poll is 8.6

it deseved nothing more thatn a ten i gave it that. it is by FAR the my favirite episode

I can't believe all these 10's....I gave it a 7...8 just didn't feel right.

i think the movie was a little rushed...i hope they come out with a extended version on dvd...a little back ground into rebel alliance...the blue glowy phase...stuff like that...there were a couple loop holes...

wow, this has made the IMDb top 250...

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0121766/

the average here is still 8.6

they're coming out with a tv show i heard thats where they're gonna put all those cut scenes from the movie in

Man... did you really have to ruin my beautiful thread with that crap?

10/10 without a doubt

Originally posted by McCusto
10/10 without a doubt

ditto!!!!!

cheers

after watching it again

Spoiler:
last night,

I think I gave it an 8 before... now I'd give it a 7.