Things you liked and didnt like about episode 3

Originally posted by bib_fortuna
thank you very much.

Sorry, but what am I being thanked for?

Originally posted by astrofan428
*uses force choke*

Apology accepted Darth_Vader05. 😛

Just kidding, I dont even know what you did, but as far as critics go, I dont understand why people who didnt like it come here and try to make us hate it too. If I dont like a movie, I put it behind me and never think about it again, not go on a message board and ***** to people and try to make them no like it too.

Same reason you come here and talk about why you like it. I didn't know KMFs were only "I like all Star Wars movies" forums.

It's a forum!

And if you guys think someone can make you hate something if you already like it then you're pretty impressionable.

Stand by your opinion..That's all you have.

...and in my opinion Sidious was freaky as heck...imagine how bad his breath must be!

Ok, this Episode had its ups..MOSTLY UPS...and downs.

Downs:

Not enough or there wasnt a MAMMOTH explosion like in the others, like planets blowing up, or like in Ep. II which is one of my favorite parts.. ((SIZMECK CHARGES!)) blowing up a big astroid. I dunno what they could of took and really make a nuke style blow up, maybe the Jedi Temple. Then again, there was no real collosial explosions in Ep. V.

Yes, Padme' could of at least on the way out fought off some battle droids, or when under the controll of Ani, Clone Troopers.

Ups:

Alot of creativity, at the beginning yes, alot of humorous creativty like the Lucas we're used to seeing...kinna like the Pod Race and the Ewok Ground War combined. But all the humor as I knew, was to all be in front and out of the way for the real emotoinal drama at the end. This is somthing that Episode V. should of been taken in consideration as well.

pros....R2 D2 was da BOMB!...omg...so0o kool...cheeky lil bastard...loved it....the duels btw anakin and obi and yoda and sid.....the scene with ani suffering and being burnt alive..that was awesome..very emotional......

cons....greivous was a bit of a disspointmnet...he seemed very fake...and...he wasnt that great.....windu/palp fight....sid took out those other jedi WAY too easily...one of them literally just stood there and let himsefl get smashed.....other than that...the rest was GREAT

I also remember I hate Obi Wans green pet he rides on

Things I like about the film:

Chewie
Palpatine
Anakin getting his ass kick by Obi
Yoda gettting his ass kick by Palpatine
Jar-Jar keeping his mouth quiet
Darth Vader
Young Aunt Beru (Hot and cute babe!)

Things I didn't like:

General Grevious
Darth Vader "NOOOOO..."
No scenes of a young Han Solo
R2 comedy relief in the begining of the film
Hayden performance as Anakin
Padme dying
No Qui-Gon ghost
No dialogue between Obi and Uncle Owen

I was hoping that in this movie we'd get to see just how powerful a jedi Anakin was. I had visions of him using the force to make spaceships crash etc but we never got to see this. In fact it was Obi Wan who showed the strongest use of the force by making the roof fall in on the grievous henchmen.

He loosened a hook or fastener. Not that hard.

Originally posted by Morning_Glory
when she is in the casket ... of course she still had the belly... i mean when a woman has a baby she doesnt automatically become super slim again with no tummy... which some movies do that.... a woman's tummy is swollon for a few weeks after giving birth

Padme had just had the twins... of course she was going to still have a belly.. tsk

Uh, maybe you didn't read what I said--I never said superslim right after giving birth. As the mother of two, trust me, *yes* you still have a belly, but *no* it no longer looks like a perfectly round beach ball--more like a deflated beach ball.

Making her look pregnant to avoid people realizing the twins were alive makes sense; I never thought of that. But as others have said, I don't see how "hiding" Luke with Anakin's stepbrother is really that secretive, unless the idea is that it would be *too* obvious. He did have Obi-wan looking over him, though...

Anyway, I thought of a few other things I liked:

Palpatine's skin-crawling eeriness when talking to Anakin about the possibility of saving someone's life, and again when Anakin finally started realizing who Palpatine really was. (I'm just surprised none of the Jedi could figure that out--geez, I knew that since ep. I).

Palpatine hoisting those seats around in the senate room. Now *that* was cool!

Vader and Palpatine gazing at the beginnings of the death star.

Overall I loved the movie, but now I feel like I'm in mourning, because it's just so sad.. It makes me want to whip out the original trilogy and watch it so that I can remember that there's a happy ending...eventually.

I severly disliked the dream scenes. Lucas has never done them and they just didn't fit. The movie seemed rushed. It definitely didn't seem like two hours. I hate the fact that Leia's connection with her mother is left hanging. It was always suspected that Leia was born first, but with Luke being the oldest, her statement just doesn't make sense. My favorite scene in the movie is when Obi-Wan and Anakin both use a force push at the same time. I really think it showed Obi-Wan's power.

it was so awesome!!!!

My favorite scene in the movie is when Obi-Wan and Anakin both use a force push at the same time. I really think it showed Obi-Wan's power. [/B][/QUOTE]

Thats something i dont get if anakin can kill dooku when obi and him were locked he should have slammed obi into a wall instead of it going both ways.

i don't like that Anakin didn't actually fall into lava. I was hoping to see Ani fall into the lava and then see some bad ass epic display of force powerage when he crawls out all burnt up and half alive. But the other way was OK.

You fall in lava, you die. Come on.

It's sci-fi fantasy, not Dragonball Z.

Bad parts :
* The beginning of the movie as several comic parts, is funny, but the film lost a lot.
* Too much CG, i hate the part where cody speaks with obi, and we clearly see, that is head is real, but the body don't.
* Who edit the movie? The movie, simply don't stop, i got lost in the middle, really...I think we deserve more slow parts, and more background stuff.
* Grievous vs Obi. Grievous jedi killer?? i think obi-wan win too easily.

Good Parts :

* Boga, so cute the sounds we does.
* The final duels.
* The emotive parts(order66, ani choking padme, crispy ani)

Thanks

i didnt like when griveous pulled out all for of his lighsabers and everyone was loocking forward to that and really they were hardly in it and most of the characters were hardly in it and yoda hehe got all sad when he lost against palpatine but hell i knew whta happend since january

Cool Stuff

All the lightsaber fights
The entire opening space battle
Grevious
Any scene that had Yoda in it (cause he kicked @ss)
the PG-13 rating (stuff like Anakin burning)
hardly any Jar Jar binks

Stuff I didn't like

The infamous "NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO"
The wookie battle was way too short
Why the hell did Gl decide to kill Mace (he was so cool)

Originally posted by Oswald Kenobi
I hate the fact that Leia's connection with her mother is left hanging. It was always suspected that Leia was born first, but with Luke being the oldest, her statement just doesn't make sense. .

See to me, it still makes sense because couldn't Leia have thought her foster mom was her real mom and maybe her "mom" dies when Leia is still young but old enough to remember her image? Whereas Luke knew all along that he was being raised by his aunt and uncle, not "mother" and "father." I mean really, even if Leia were born first, it would have only been by a matter of moments, plus, you can't expect to have any lasting memory of your mother if she died the day you were born; does anyone really remember anything from the day they were born? So it still wouldn't have totally made sense even if she had been born first.

Originally posted by Red Superfly
You fall in lava, you die. Come on.

It's sci-fi fantasy, not Dragonball Z.

Well they explicitly said in the OT that that fool somehow finds himself in a vat of lava.