Originally posted by starlock
I think the issue with wolverine is....he has always been a dark character....and his attitude has always been the same...in this day and age....comic charaters are becoming darker...the tone of comics has become darker...it has just become what mkes wolverine so popular...its his time to shine...its his era to be the standard that is to be set..he can be hurt..put down...but he will always get back up..to the everyday man and woman...he is the hero of today..i.m.o
I read an interesting article once, "The Psychology of the Superhero," something along those lines by some PHD or another.
His point (a fairly obvious one) was that people- particularly younger, comic book reading people, your stereotypical "nerd," if you want- have a tendency to identify with the X-Men out of feelings of alienation and "other"ness. The X-Men, too, are ostracized outcasts, but they belong to a fabulous band of sexy adventurers with powers and abilities far beyond those of a "normal" person.
What kind of individual who feels alienated wouldn't want to identify with that? It's the same thing as the Spiderman mythos, and really, the whole idea of the superhero secret identity- "I may not look like much to you, and so you make fun of me, but if you knew the real me, you'd be awestruck." So people identify with the X-Men because it's the idealized group of friends and family, despite all their dysfunction.
Wolverine is popular, psychologically, because he represents an idealized protector within that familial structure: mentoring to the young initiates (Kitty Pride, Jubilee, you could on forever), but also "cool"- he smokes, drinks, he rides a motorcycle, he has wonderful collequalisms for everything. And he won't hesitate to use everything within his power to protect you.
So, basically, the reason so many younger comic readers find him to be such a great character is because they not only want someone like him in their life- a cool, powerful protector- but they also want to be someone like him.
It's the same reason why Captain Marvel sold so much better than Superman did back in the Golden Age. Captain Marvel was the idealized adult, but at heart he was just a person like yourself (if you happened to be a young comic book reader).
Of course, if you happen to be an awesome and popular individual, you're much more likely to enjoy Scott Pilgrim to Logan.