Will star wars 4-6 be remade?

Originally posted by jaden101
yeah...they would be much better...just like get carter, rollerball, the italian job, the lady killers, alfie, shaft, the stepford wives, the shining and planet of the apes were all better than the originals

hang on a minute...no they weren't

and while we're at it

neither were the ring, the ring 2, house of wax, psycho, the texas chainsaw massacre, lolita, dawn of the dead, carrie, the island of Dr moreau or war of the worlds

infact i dont think i've ever seen a remake that was better than the original

FACT

whats all this bullshit about mistakes in the OT?

they have no mistakes, the PT is responsible for any errors... simple fact...

Exactomundo. If I was to somehow magically edit ROTJ without harming what is already there, I would replace the Ewoks with Wookies, and perhaps change Endor's name to Kashyyyk. I'd also remove all the new musical numbers, like 'Jedi Rocks' and the new celebration song at the end. I don't know about a second death star either - sounds like a bit of a cop-out. But I tell you what, unless, like I said, I could edit these magically without harming the rest of the movie, I wouldn't touch it. And I sure as hell wouldn't touch ANH or ESB.

Jesus H ChRIST

We don't need these films remade! Gayest thread ever

Originally posted by JediMasterLuke5
I think they should be remade, and if they are they should have references to Mace Windu and Qui-gon Ginn. The Originals have so many mistakes, such as Yoda was Obi-wan's master. Also the lightsaber fights are not as well done in the originals, Luke should be alot better duelist than he is in Ep6. They need to show them using more force powers also. Also my biggest problem is why in the heck in Ep 4 when Vader has Leia captured why doesnt he try to turn her to the Dark side? And plus with such new technology the special effects will look better then ever, there will be no more puppets. If they remade the movies theyd be a whole lot better and there wouldnt be as many mistakes.

Personally i dont see many mistakes with the original three. Obi-wan never said i was yoda's padawan.. he just said that yoda instructed him, which is true.. he was also trained.. primarily, by qui gon... but yoda trained all younglings at some point..

and vader didnt try to convert leia because he didnt know she was his daughter.. he didnt know he had twins. he only found out after he learned from luke.....

and as far as the special effects are concerned.. personally my biggest problem with the new three are that the effects rely way way way too much on computers.. i say the puppets where great and they should never redo the original three.. ever.. bad bad idea

Originally posted by JediMasterLuke5
I think they should be remade, and if they are they should have references to Mace Windu and Qui-gon Ginn. The Originals have so many mistakes, such as Yoda was Obi-wan's master. Also the lightsaber fights are not as well done in the originals, Luke should be alot better duelist than he is in Ep6. They need to show them using more force powers also. Also my biggest problem is why in the heck in Ep 4 when Vader has Leia captured why doesnt he try to turn her to the Dark side? And plus with such new technology the special effects will look better then ever, there will be no more puppets. If they remade the movies theyd be a whole lot better and there wouldnt be as many mistakes.

Yeah, remake it so they can mention Mace and Qui-Gon once in a while! Not kidding, but that is actually the best goddamn idea I have ever read!!

The Originals have so many mistakes, such as Yoda was Obi-wan's master

Ever considered the PT has changed everything and therefor having the potential mistakes you mention?

Also the lightsaber fights are not as well done in the originals, Luke should be alot better duelist than he is in Ep6.

They can't change it and they should just let the damn movie be.

They need to show them using more force powers also.

It would suck if everybody constantly used force powers, they should only be used at the right moment to give an impression or as some sort of climax.

Also my biggest problem is why in the heck in Ep 4 when Vader has Leia captured why doesnt he try to turn her to the Dark side?

After the movie was made, a lot more aspects came to be in the story as Leia being force sensitive, Vaders daughter and stuff.
I see no need to change that, it's useless and people don't convert to the dark side through torture, only through themselves.
And Vader new nothing of course about her being force sensitive.

If they remade the movies theyd be a whole lot better and there wouldnt be as many mistakes.

They are perfectly good movies and much improvement would probably not be possible without throwing everything upside down, then they could just as well make another SW trilogy. But changes will probably just be useless and sucky just like the other ones.

This movie was made and there were no so called mistakes untill the PT came out.

But to return to subject, this movie is made and it is good, it shouldn't be done again, that is a waste of time. Then they could just as well make up a whole new story without Vader and Sidious and such. To change would be to kill the whole story of SW.

Episode 4-6= Should never be remade.

They will never remake episodes 4-6 because they don't need to. Its good enough.

The PT should be redone to fit the OT. Then there woulnd tbe people saying the OT has 'mistakes'

kids....sigh

😘

no seriously, who would ever fathom the idea that the originals should be remade instead of the other way around?

These kids secretly didn't even bother to watch the OT!
They just presume ROTS is teh best because of the nice colors!

I feel so strongly about the fact the shouldnt be remade i believe all starwars fans agree at least true ones...Im not saying you have to know where everything to be a true fan but you need a real feel for the characters...during Episode three When order 66 (the killing of the jedi took place) I had tears in my eyes and it was soo hard to keep them there I had to wipe them all the time and when Obi-wan said he luved Anakin even after all that he didcrybaby. Im sure u r a nice guy mr Darkperson but Trying to redo starwars is sick next i suppose you'll try to give Jar Jar a lightsaber

I certainly hope not. I was 14 in 1977 when the original Star Wars was released. Over the course of that summer I saw the movie 8 times, not at a multiplex but at a single theatre that stood by itself. Star Wars was WAY ahead of it's time. My parents both loved the flick as did my younger sister. The whole country went nuts for a movie that sold the second most number of tickets EVER at the box office, only Gone With The Wind has sold more. When The Empire Strikes Back came three years later I was a little older, 17, and had more of an appreciation of what these movies meant. There was still the Iran hostage crisis, unemployment was high, I was facing my senior year in high school. This movie was a great distraction in hard times for our country. Three years later, in 1983 some of the magic had worn off. The Star Wars concept was getting tired, the mood of the country was changing, and the Ewoks were corny. What happened with the first two flicks can never happen again. Some movies aren't meant to be remade. I commend George Lucas for trying with the last three flicks but he couldn't recapture what happened the first time around, though Revenge of the Sith was a decent flick. Anyone who was into the first series when it first came out understands exactly what I mean here. The original Star Wars was far more than just a movie, it was THE icon of it's time. No movie since has managed to do that, and probably never will.

No... please no remakes. At the the OT has spirit, soul, the PT kinda lacks that. Even in ROTS.

Hasn't anyone watched that South Park episode where a caricature of Steven Spielberg was cast in a villainous role? Spielberg sent Stone "the meanest nicest letter..." and it seemed the episode discouraged him from making another remake... it also touched on Lucas and the Star Wars remakes.

Where's the letter?

It must have been a jew to jew sort of thing rather than material for the common property of the rest of the world 😕

Hmmm, I sense antisemitism.... You nazi! 😛

I think a remake with lots of cooler scenes to make them link with PT would be mint/cool.

Don't touch ESB... it'll only get worse. The additions in the SE and DVD were already useless.