Debate 3 - Will we ever see Sirius again?

Originally posted by Phoenix
Phoe's Crazy Theory: Sirius comes back in a painting, there must be one of him somewhere...

I like your Crazy Theory as well. Sounds like a great thought.

I'm still, also, for the idea of him coming back as a dementor. But that would be NightCrawler's Crazy Theory.

Originally posted by DanZeke25
No. JK said he was dead

Originally posted by hopeful_dreamer
She didn't specifically say that.
Anyways, Luna said that it wasn't as if Harry could never see him again. I do think that it wasn't the last we've seen of him. It's a magical universe people. Anything can happen. I hope we do see him again. He was my favorite character. He is the reason why I loved PoA so much.

Originally posted by TheSun
JKR said it through Lupin, Dumbledore, Hagrid and just about everyone else. However you are right in saying that we may see him again, I don't quite know how though, definitely not as a ghost or picture though.

why not as a ghost or picture 😖 ... it could happen

Johnny, I believe I have repeated this many times now. He can't come back as a ghost because Nearly Headless Nick said he can't. And I don't think he can become a picture because the would probably need him there for the making of the picture.

But there might already BE a painting

Normal wizard paintings are just a recording of a few catchphrases like Mrs Black's. Only former heads of Hogwarts (who use the circular office) can leave a faint imprint of themselves behind in portrait form.

They could use one of the wanted signs, I guess.

I think sirius will come back in some way, a way that probably only harry can achieve. i mean that only harry can contact sirius in that way. perhaps only the closest person to sirius, or the person that sirius worry about most before he died. it might come as a form of memory? and the two way mirror, it definately be of some use. i don't believe jk will create it just so that harry will smash it. such a good idea! a two way mirror! how can she let go of it like that without making some story out of it?

i hope to see sirius again! even if not as a live person.

*Sings under breathe awkwardly* Dementor, dementor, dementor...

sirius should come back as a ghost haunting grimauld place why the f*** did JK kill him off in the first place why couldnt granger be the one to die?or even umbridge thatll be much better
"her body was found in the forbbiden forest trampled by cenataurs"
a person can dream

Umbridge can do with a worse fate than that.

i know but thats probably what softy JK would say

People. He's dead. We all gotta cope(sp?) with it. *DEMENTOR!*

I thought she said that he was dead and not coming back? o.O Idk.

I think Harry is going to turn to Lupin now that Sirius is gone.

Then Lupin is going to die. Harry is losing a lot of people.

Okay, now THAT would suck!

Actually I think he is supposed to be in the 3rd movie .I know he does have tiny parts in the book.

It was very weird the way h died i mean he fell through a veil but wasnt he hit with a curse from his cousin
membere b4 he fell he was hit and had a scared face on
and why did lupin stop harry from looking i mean its not like he would jump in