Debate 3 - Will we ever see Sirius again?

I hope he comes back as a ghost!

Originally posted by Harry_Monkey
I hope he comes back as a ghost!

Sorry Im not all obsessed about it like you are!

Originally posted by Phoenix
I don't think Sirius is going to come back to life, as JK has alreasdy said he is really dead, but I definitely think we [b]will see him again. I think nearly everyone already knows my theory, but here it is again for anyone who missed it!

Phoe's Crazy Theory: Sirius comes back in a painting, there must be one of him somewhere... [/B]

That's what I thought 😖mart: He can't be completely dead and detatched from the books.. he's still some significant role to play cry

Originally posted by Harry_Monkey
Sorry Im not all obsessed about it like you are!

I did read the book.

Then whats the fuss? Maybe he read it more carefully than you did, Harry Monkey. That doesn't make him obsessed. Please respect each other people.

Originally posted by Harry_Monkey
I did read the book.

I can name two people then...

Originally posted by NightCrawler341
I can name two people then...

Yeah, what he said. Na, I don't think Sirius is coming back.

The Grim lives, The Grim lives!!!!

|
|
\/

I don't think Sirius is coming back either, and i really don't think he will be behind the veil, then again i could just be wrong

Behind veil, killed him. If you don't die by going through the veil then why did Lupin stop Harry from going through. So, yea.

I agree

you know what i think? i dont think he's really dead. i think that the veil is a doorway to the land of the dead, where SPIRITS go after they die. but sirius, on the other hand, fell in along with his BODY. so i think that he's trapped in the land of the dead - ALIVE!

so the happy conclusion is - SIRIUS LIVES!!! *throws a party*

.... Then Harry can go and get him... Lupin would go too... they would go and find him and find a way to get him out. If there wasn't a way to get him, then it doesn't matter if he is alive, he will sooner or later die because one, no one can get him, and two, he will starve to death.

Its funny how you say he's behind the veil, when are can walk around the veil, and nothings there. Kind of like a invisabilty(sp?) cloak. I never noticed that the can walk around the veil and look at it from behind. I guess I never really paid attention to it.

Originally posted by AndaliteGal
you know what i think? i dont think he's really dead. i think that the veil is a doorway to the land of the dead, where SPIRITS go after they die. but sirius, on the other hand, fell in along with his BODY. so i think that he's trapped in the land of the dead - ALIVE!

so the happy conclusion is - SIRIUS LIVES!!! *throws a party*

Not everything in the world ends happy. This could be one of those times when it doesn't.

I agree

me too