Should they totally remake 4,5 and 6

But if they remade the ot you could have it all, the great character based story with the added advantage of seeing Darths full power which you don't see in the OT. You got to admit the duals are pretty weak

i agree with revan. if they put better effects in with the exact same plot and story and emotion, it will be the best saga ever! (not that it allready isnt)

Originally posted by Revan Souer
But if they remade the ot you could have it all, the great character based story with the added advantage of seeing Darths full power which you don't see in the OT. You got to admit the duals are pretty weak

Wait a minute, do you mean remake the OT with the existing footage or remake the OT COMPLETELY?

Updating the OT? Sure, as long as it's done right this time.

Remaking it? Hell no.

Originally posted by The Ones
i agree with revan. if they put better effects in with the exact same plot and story and emotion, it will be the best saga ever! (not that it allready isnt)

[QUOTE=4148930]Originally posted by Red Superfly
[B]Wait a minute, do you mean remake the OT with the existing footage or remake the OT COMPLETELY?
If they could update the OT which made VADA seem like the most powerful jedi ever then great but I just can't see them making that work

Vader is in a frickin suit, has no real limbs, and relies on a mask to stay alive! He's NOT the most powerful Jedi ever! Which is why Palpatine wanted Luke. Because Luke would be everything Vader could be without the suit...

Having Machine parts shouldn't effect a Jedi, Sith or not. As a Little green thing said "Judge me by my size do you. As well you should not"
Quite simply the six films don't match and the only way of doing it is to remake ep456. They could even use Portman as Leia, bet you'd wanna watch that

No because Carrie Fisher is Leia......

🤨

So you expect to see Vader jumping around the room like a frog on speed?

Ya know what the smart thing would've been? To make the PT in line with the OT. duh.

If anyone remakes the OT I will personally hammer rusty nails into their ears and gouge out their eyes.

Originally posted by DeVi| D0do
So you expect to see Vader jumping around the room like a frog on speed?

Ya know what the smart thing would've been? To make the PT in line with the OT. duh.

If anyone remakes the OT I will personally hammer rusty nails into their ears and gouge out their eyes.

Haha. I'm really not. I just don't see the point in remaking these almost-perfect movies (ESB anyway).

If they were to be remade they'd have the style of the PT which I hate.

Anyway, why are we even discussing this? IT'S NOT GONNA HAPPEN!

Originally posted by DeVi| D0do
Haha. I'm really not. I just don't see the point in remaking these almost-perfect movies (ESB anyway).

If they were to be remade they'd have the style of the PT which I hate.

Anyway, why are we even discussing this? IT'S NOT GONNA HAPPEN!

I would be happy for them to update the OT some more. The picture quality is consistent with the prequels, and some of the effects have been updated sufficiently, they just need to get their act together and nail those other technical issues they missed (and created by simply trying and failing to make it better eg lukes green saber in ANH).

Would be fine if they added new effects to the existing print and just do the job they should have done for the DVD's

I have no problem with them updating the OT.

The saber FX NEED to be fixed! I just can't stand to watch Vader with a pink lightsaber. In the 'Making Of' book Lucas says when reviewing the OT DVDs that the Bespin shot needs to be updated 'for any future releases'. Good call. And they really need to fix Jabba in ANH, he just looks horible. I'd also not have a problem with updating the space battle at the end of ANH. And by that I don't mean making it longer or changing any camera angles - I think it's great how it is - but getting rid of some of the horrible out-dated model work. It just looks shamefull with all the other updates...

Yeah. There's an awful failed shot of a very tiny-looking (but meant to be huge) power conduit that an X-Wing blows up. It has electricity surging around it and it looks bloody awful.

Things like that, the failed lightsabers, the pixelated boxes and some of the bad animations need to be updated.

I wouldn't mind if they CGI-ified some of the plasticine model work - namely the Tauntaun from ESB and the Chess Match in ANH. The animation looks crap and a nice bit of CGI would be a lot better.

mm, If they can make the tauntaun look the same (but move more fluidly) and not look like those turds in the PT (namely the Eopie) I'd be happy. But I like the chess game looking stop-motioned 😄

They also need to fix the Rancor. And I don't mean the animatronic work which I think is fine, but there are shots where you can just totally tell it's fake. (eg when Luke goes to put the bone in its mouth - awful).

What about the Jaba sceen they added to ep1, something has to be done with that

i think they shouldn't change the story line but just update the techstarwars
ps i agree wit the part that ben v vader wasn't very good

tomcat i love planes

I dont want to see a TOTAL REMAKE of the OT with different actors. just update the effects so it fits in to the PT since the PT kicked ass.

heres a list of things i would like to see changed in the OT

Lukes green and white sabers to be blue

Jabba in ANH and (even worse) in ROTJ to be better

change vaders lightsaber to red

update the space battle as you can see the green around the ties of where they shot it seperatly and tried to blend in (mostly in anh)

use a bit more cg to make ben and vader better (the fight, not the characters)

the asteroid monster needs to be changed so its not obviously a hand puppet

taun tauns better

SS cg to make it look like there the same as the ones from ROTS

(if possible) make the computers in the death star more like the ones weve seen in ROTS.

i think thats everything

Originally posted by The Ones
I dont want to see a TOTAL REMAKE of the OT with different actors. just update the effects so it fits in to the PT since the PT kicked ass.

heres a list of things i would like to see changed in the OT

Lukes green and white sabers to be blue

Jabba in ANH and (even worse) in ROTJ to be better

change vaders lightsaber to red

update the space battle as you can see the green around the ties of where they shot it seperatly and tried to blend in (mostly in anh)

use a bit more cg to make ben and vader better (the fight, not the characters)

the asteroid monster needs to be changed so its not obviously a hand puppet

taun tauns better

SS cg to make it look like there the same as the ones from ROTS

(if possible) make the computers in the death star more like the ones weve seen in ROTS.

i think thats everything