a total remake? agree with you i do not
the actors are superb the way they are. if they remade everything including the actors then it wont be watchable. i cant see anyone taking the place of carrie, mark or harrison. they ARE the characters. and they cant remake it with the original actors cause they look so different and older. not good. updating the effects will make the OT better. but a total remake, will be georges last seconds on earth
Originally posted by The Ones
a total remake? agree with you i do notthe actors are superb the way they are. if they remade everything including the actors then it wont be watchable. i cant see anyone taking the place of carrie, mark or harrison. they ARE the characters. and they cant remake it with the original actors cause they look so different and older. not good. updating the effects will make the OT better. but a total remake, will be georges last seconds on earth
Originally posted by Lana
I liked puppet Yoda FAR better than CG Yoda, personally.And guys, the duel between Obi-wan and Vader in ANH isn't supposed to be insanely good like the PT duels. It's an old man vs. someone who's half man-half machine, and who are probably quite out of practice with duelling.
Hmm I didn't like puppet Yoda.....they could have made him look decent at least.
As for the Battle between Ben and Vader....just because they didn'T jump around like crazy doesbn't mean that thedy fought worse....they just waited for the other to make a mistake...if Vader suddenly had decided to jump over Ben and make two 360° Ben would have just cut him in half.....I don't get this crazy notion that the firght between Obi Wan and Young Vader must have been better just because they jumped around a lot.....
Originally posted by Bardock42
Hmm I didn't like puppet Yoda.....they could have made him look decent at least.As for the Battle between Ben and Vader....just because they didn'T jump around like crazy doesbn't mean that thedy fought worse....they just waited for the other to make a mistake...if Vader suddenly had decided to jump over Ben and make two 360° Ben would have just cut him in half.....I don't get this crazy notion that the firght between Obi Wan and Young Vader must have been better just because they jumped around a lot.....
Originally posted by Revan Souer
I don't mean jumping around just more dramatic, Ben(Alec Guinese) was to old to really fight, but an aged Ewan would do great. I could be wrong but the lightsaber also looked crap 😈
Yes, well I wasn't refering to you actually...I was just saying in general that their fighting style doesn't necessarily have to be worse.
And I wouldn't mind a remake in a few years either but I also don't really need it...
Are you all crazy? Episodes IV, V, and VI are classics and remaking them would be the most blasphemous thing anyone could ever do or even think about. Do you call yourselves fans? This is disgraceful. I can't believe anyone would ever suggest it. Adding the Jabba the Hutt scene in A New Hope was terrible, it looked awful and took away from the original masterpeice. Would anybody paint highlights in the hair of the Mona Lisa? No, and you should be ashamed of thinking of remaking some of the best movies ever made. It would cheapen the remake and also cheapen the original just like they did with Psycho.
Originally posted by Lord Chariolyou make a very good arguement you might of changed my mind well done
Are you all crazy? Episodes IV, V, and VI are classics and remaking them would be the most blasphemous thing anyone could ever do or even think about. Do you call yourselves fans? This is disgraceful. I can't believe anyone would ever suggest it. Adding the Jabba the Hutt scene in A New Hope was terrible, it looked awful and took away from the original masterpeice. Would anybody paint highlights in the hair of the Mona Lisa? No, and you should be ashamed of thinking of remaking some of the best movies ever made. It would cheapen the remake and also cheapen the original just like they did with Psycho.