Originally posted by Mr.V
But the off panel smack would be enough, ie someone can be shot with a gun then dropped on a sponge, doesnt mean the sponge killed them 😄
Like I said before: Thor send him flying around the universe twice, smashed his nutsack with his hammer and sang army songs for twelve hours straight before the actual impalement occured 🙂
We all know that's what happened off screen 😆
Originally posted by Dinalfos
Neither one of those count. The What If is just that, a what if. The other one is just plain ridiculous.
To have something like that happen in a What If? issue, shows the editors and writers aren't going to protect the Hulk through PIS and CIS, and show that Thor has it within his power to kill Hulk. They can let it happen, without disturbing normal continuity.
King Thor killing Hulk & Thing with one arm - call it ridiculous, but it still happened.
Originally posted by roughrider
To have something like that happen in a What If? issue, shows the editors and writers aren't going to protect the Hulk through PIS and CIS, and show that Thor has it within his power to kill Hulk. They can let it happen, without disturbing normal continuity.
King Thor killing Hulk & Thing with one arm - call it ridiculous, but it still happened.
No. It was the PIS that killed the Hulk.
Sure, it happened. Spiderman also defeated Firelord.
Originally posted by roughrider
To have something like that happen in a What If? issue, shows the editors and writers aren't going to protect the Hulk through PIS and CIS, and show that Thor has it within his power to kill Hulk. They can let it happen, without disturbing normal continuity.
King Thor killing Hulk & Thing with one arm - call it ridiculous, but it still happened.
Again, Thor would win, but not in a purely physical fight, especially not by breaking the Hulk's neck or impaling him through the gut.
I could be wrong, but in my opinion Hulk is not on the same lv as Mangog.
In Thor v2 84, Mangog came running at Thor full charge. Thor put his right arm up, and stopped Mangog in his tracks. Thor then muttered a word, and Mangog just blew up. This is all without his hammer, meaning Thor has learned to fight without Mjolnir.
Thor 10/10
Originally posted by Soujaboy
I could be wrong, but in my opinion Hulk is not on the same lv as Mangog.In Thor v2 84, Mangog came running at Thor full charge. Thor put his right arm up, and stopped Mangog in his tracks. Thor then muttered a word, and Mangog just blew up. This is all without his hammer, meaning Thor has learned to fight without Mjolnir.
Thor 10/10
Uh, yeah.... Mangog is definitely above Hulk. 😉
Originally posted by Soujaboy
I think so to, but I said that because I don't want to be killed by the Hulk fans.
Nothing wrong with thinking Mangog could be above Hulk.
He has high stats.
Real Name: Mangog
Aliases: (former) Odin
Height: 12'
Weight: 3,500 lbs
Eyes: Brown
Hair: None
Distinguishing Features: Horns on head, prehensile tail, two clawed fingers on each hand, three clawed toes on each foot.
Occupation: Seeker of vengeance, (former - when disguised as Odin) Monarch of Asgard
Citizenship: Inapplicable
Place of Creation/Birth: Possibly inapplicable
Known Relatives: None, possibly inapplicable
Known Allies: (former) Igron
Known Enemies: Odin, Thor, Balder, gods of Asgard
Intelligence: Normal (4/10)
Strength: Incalculable (12/12)
Speed: Superhuman (6/10)
Stamina: Immeasurable (10/10)
Durability: Demi-godlike (11/14)
Agility: Superhuman (6/7)
Reflexes: Superhuman (6/7)
Fighting Skills: None, relies on sheer force
Special Skills/Abilities: None
Superhuman physical powers: Mangog has the ability to manipulate vast magical energies for various effects, including projection of concussive force, molecular manipulation of others.
Superhuman Mental Powers: None
Special Limitations: The Mangog will shrink or seemingly vanish if deprived of the mystical/psionic energies that give him his superhuman power
Source of Superhuman Powers: Originally, the Mangog drew his superhuman power from the mystical/psionic energies manifested in the hatred and desire for vengeance felt by others or himself. Later, when disguised as Odin, he sustained himself by the psychic energies of the Asgardians' strong devotion to Odin.
NOTE: the exact nature of the Mangog is unclear. He has often been called a demon, suggesting that he is a supernatural being parasitically dependent on the mystic/psionic energies of other sentient beings. It is also possible that the Mangog is a minor abstract entity incarnating the hatred felt by the alien race, and later, by himself. In that case he may be an avatar of the conceptual entity Hate.
Personal Weaponry: None
Other Accessories: None
You know we dont really know what happened in the off panel seen. The tree thru the mid section may and probably was not what killed hulk. For all we know he may have been fighting with the tree in his gut until he got killed. We didnt see the other side of his body. Look what Thor did to caps shield. Whats tougher hulks hide or caps shield??
Hulk fans just wont accept that Thor killed Hulk and Thing at the same time with one hand. we cant judge what happened off panel, because we don't know what happened, all we can do is speculate.
Now I know that Hulk fans are gonna argue that when Savage Hulk is enraged he can't be killed, but he was.
Originally posted by Dinalfos
He died by impalement, which is impossible.
See, this is what we've come to with Hulk, since he was retconned in 1987 to have a healing factor. Now, people will argue he can't be killed at all, his body will regenerate from anything...If Wolverine decapitated him, will he grow a new head, too? 🙄
They want him to be Doomsday, instead of what he was before.
Originally posted by roughrider
See, this is what we've come to with Hulk, since he was retconned in 1987 to have a healing factor. Now, people will argue he can't be killed at all, his body will regenerate from anything...If Wolverine decapitated him, will he grow a new head, too? 🙄They want him to be Doomsday, instead of what he was before.
It's not us. It's Marvel. They are the ones who provide the statistics and handbooks. Also, blame the writers.