Thor vs. Hulk

Exactly; a healing factor doesn't mean your immortal.

Originally posted by Dinalfos
It's not us. It's Marvel. They are the ones who provide the statistics and handbooks. Also, blame the writers.

Marvel Comics never stated that Hulk can't physically die.

He has more than just a healing factor. He has vast superhuman durability that increases with anger. And being extremely hard to kill is not the same a being immortal.

Originally posted by Soujaboy
Marvel Comics never stated that Hulk can't physically die.

He can be killed, but it takes exceptional force to pull it off. Also, if he can regenerate from nothingness, then impalement isn't going to do much.

So having high durability makes you impossible to kill? um no.

He's really not that hard to kill Thor showed us that, it's just Marvel can't allow him to die. That however isn't the rules of these forums.

Originally posted by Dinalfos
He can be killed, but it takes exceptional force to pull it off. Also, if he can regenerate from nothingness, then impalement isn't going to do much.

I've never seen Hulk regenerate from nothingness. I've seen Maestro do it, but Maestro is a different character than Savage Hulk.

Originally posted by Soujaboy
So having high durability makes you impossible to kill? um no.

He's really not that hard to kill Thor showed us that, it's just Marvel can't allow him to die. That however isn't the rules of these forums.

Who said anything about impossible? I'm sure some god-like creature with enough power can destroy him. Just not through impalement.

Thor showed how bad PIS can get.

Originally posted by Soujaboy
I've never seen Hulk regenerate from nothingness. I've seen Maestro do it, but Maestro is a different character than Savage Hulk.

If Maestro can do it, then Savage can do as well. Because Maestro is an evolved version of Prof. Hulk, who is rather weak in comparison. Savage Hulk still considered the ultimate incarnation of Hulk. Besides, Savage Hulk has never had the chance to regenerate from nothingness, because he's never been destroyed.

like Roughrider and I have stated, you don't know what happened so why speculate?

Thing was shown dead with Thor's foot on his chest, does that means Thor killed him by stepping on him?

Hulk was physically beaten and killed, thats all we know that happened.

Originally posted by Soujaboy
like Roughrider and I have stated, you don't know what happened so why speculate?

Thing was shown dead with Thor's foot on his chest, does that means Thor killed him by stepping on him?

Hulk was physically beaten and killed, thats all we know that happened.

No, that's all you like to see. Like you said, speculation. But showing the Hulk impaled AND dead as a horse, implies a lot.

Originally posted by Dinalfos
If Maestro can do it, then Savage can do as well. Because Maestro is an evolved version of Prof. Hulk, who is rather weak in comparison. Savage Hulk still considered the ultimate incarnation of Hulk. Besides, Savage Hulk has never had the chance to regenerate from nothingness, because he's never been destroyed.

Maestro is a far advanced version of Hulk. He absorbed a lot more gamma radiation than savage hulk did and has. Saying Savage Hulk can do what Maestro can do is like saying Classic Thor can do what RTK can do.

the ultimate Incarnation of Hulk is War Hulk, not savage.

Originally posted by Dinalfos
No, that's all you like to see. Like you said, speculation. But showing the Hulk impaled AND dead as a horse, implies a lot.

No, thats all I saw, and all I was given. I can claim no more than what i saw.

Originally posted by Soujaboy
No, thats all I saw, and all I was given. I can claim no more than what i saw.

And what we saw was incorrect. Fallacious. PIS.

All You saw was Hulk dead, so are you saying Hulk dieing is "fallacious PIS". No matter how much you can't stand it Hulk died, and it was shown in that comic.

Ok man I know thor can beat hulk, And looking at the picture it's almost clear to see he died from that impalment since there is not a lot of green blood around the rock or tree, or Thor dropped him on it after he killed him but that's just speculation ( than there is to much green blood around it).

Hulk doesn't have a normal body.
He is walking gamma radiation so his healing ability would work much difrent than a normal or mutated body.

Originally posted by Soujaboy
All You saw was Hulk dead, so are you saying Hulk dieing is "fallacious PIS". No matter how much you can't stand it Hulk died, and it was shown in that comic.

They showed it.......Through PIS 😆

I don't really believe he could die that way.

I understand that Hulk has a great healing factor, but against an uber god it really doesn't seem to matter.

Note: Thor killed Hulk and Thing "physically" without his Mjolnir, so there go's a lot of peoples argument that Thor can't beat Hulk without his hammer.

Originally posted by Brutacus
I don't really believe he could die that way.

I don't believe that he would die by impalement either, but I also don't think thats what happened.

I believe the "killing" of Hulk was done to impress the Thor reader. After all, they could conveniantly turn back time after that, so why the hell not? But it just doesn't make sense.