Originally posted by chilled monkey
You said it. I agree 100%.
If I murdered someone for a laugh, would that be good 'from a certain POV?' Of course not!
your stupid really. i don't agreee with this thread the jedi had the right to take palps down.
But evil is just a point of view if someone kills someone because they're mad does that make them evil, no. people that kill other people for a laugh don't think it is wrong to kill people therefore they are not evil.
Take Hitler as an example he did not believe that he was evil he felt that he wa doing the right thing, he felt he was doing it for the best.
therefore evil is a pont of view and there is no such thing as an evil person. people don't jst do things because they think it is an evil thing to do.
I think people are forgetting that this is Star Wars, and there is a pretty simple black and white distinction between good and evil.
Palpatine tries to cast doubt, talking about point of views and such. That was to dupe Anakin. Ironic, that it has also duped so many fans too.
Palpatine was evil. Mace killing Palpatine would have been a good thing.
Mace just had awful timing and picked 3 punks to accompany him.
Palpatine is bad. Simple as that. Killing him would be good. Palpatine, as stated by Lucas, is a consciousless evil. Comparring him to Hitler isn't feasable. Hitler was misguided, Palpatine is just evil personified.
He is the Snake from Adam and Eve, he is the devil. There is no redeeming qualities in him.
Fully agree, but careful with the "3 punks to accompany him" comment 🙂
You are going to get all the EU guys all pissy. They will come back with lavish stories of how powerful those 3 guys were, and how they can create black holes and manipulate time itself in comic books or some dumb EU shit and this thread will go on for another 10 pages...
Ya they were faggots no doubt, but go over to EU section and Versus forum and you'll see how many people think they are gods for some reason...
How did the first guy to die not see that slow, long ass thrust move that impailed him? Was he on the tail end of a drunken bender or something. He wasen't even looking at palps when he died.
Originally posted by DarkYodaDudes, chill. I already apologised for what I said... I was talking about something else.
Quit picking on that Dodo!😆
I agree completely with Superfly's post.
Originally posted by DarkYodaI don't agree with that completely. An evil person knows others' perception of him is evil but to himself he is not evil.
An evil person I think knows he's evil...
Originally posted by DarkYodaYes, I agree with that.
What I think DD was trying to say though is that evil and bad can be hard to define at times... one person's freedom fighter is another person's terrorist sort of thing. 😉
Well, I can understand number one and two going out, but number 3 (Fisto right?) was just retarded. What the hell was he thinking?
Fisto: "Ooh, Palpatine, we gonna kick yo' ass!"
*Palpatine kills first Jedi*
Fisto: "WTF? Where's my saber? Oh god! WTF!" *fumbles*
*Palpatine kills second Jedi*
Fisto: "Oh crap! If I don't get my saber out soon I'm f*cked! AHA! Here it is......sh*t, which way is up on this thing? I don't want to stab myself when I turn it on. Maybe it's this button he...."
*Palpatine cuts Fisto*
Originally posted by jango fat
Like da jedi didn't kill billions of people. HUH
Da empire also wants peace. Da first thing Palpie says after he killed Mace was something like'And now there shall be peace'
Da rebels were just stupid. They started it as did da jedi. Palpie had every right to execute order 66
the sith have no problem with obtaining peace through violence. A hypocritical belief usually isnt somthing to bank on. The sith are narcissitic. You ever notice that the sith always claim to have the answers? One of the oldest sayings that still remians true can apply in this case. "He who claims to be a wise man, isnt"
Originally posted by Vanquish
Fully agree, but careful with the "3 punks to accompany him" comment 🙂You are going to get all the EU guys all pissy. They will come back with lavish stories of how powerful those 3 guys were, and how they can create black holes and manipulate time itself in comic books or some dumb EU shit and this thread will go on for another 10 pages...
Yo Vanquish, I'm an EU fan and I wont even deny that they were weak-ass punks. They might as well have been one of those useless skinny battle droids--they provided no help to Mace. And why that twatt Agen Kolar had his back to Palpatine...beyond me.
Re: The Jedi had no right to arrest Palpatine
Originally posted by king_arthur
Palpatine still has the right to be Supreme Chancellor, even if he was recognized as a Sith.What Mace and the other Jedi did was discrimination because they wanted to arrest Palpatine since he was a Sith. And according to Republic Law, stopping someone because of their religions or beliefs is discrimination. This is why what the Jedi did was treason.
It was explained in the novelization.