Dooku, Vader, and Maul vs. Anakin, Luke, and Obi-wan

Originally posted by Admiral Akbar
I would rather believe the novel than the moive. And palps aimed at kits head in the movie, if you never noticed that....
Dooku changed styles, not just ROTs says that. You dont need to be a syle nerd when all u do is compare dooku (aotc) to (rots)

Hmm....Weird.... I SEE KIT'S CHEST BEING SLICED! NOTICE THAT!

Dooku was using his Form in the movie. Form II (AKA Makashi or way of the Ysalamir) Was being used in his defense and in his attacks. You could see this because he was practically fencing in his defense maneuvours. And any LIGHTSABER FORM NERD knows that Form II is almost exactly like old ancient english fencing tactics. This is what he used in the movie.

Well, my cousin(major SW guru) and my family friend Tim have both said that Dooku isn't using a fencing form in either movie. In ep2 the guy who played Dooku didn't learn it fast enough and in ep3 he wasnt using it on purpose. I believe my friend on fencing, he got 47th in the nation in fencing, so he knows a lot about it.

i cant see the picture on that link, so im going to believe you until i see it.
He never sticked with it throughout the battle, he switched his styles dramatically, he was never alwayz in a defensive pose, he took offensive lead and cut back on the fencing at one point in the battle, so u are 50% correct.

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
Well, my cousin(major SW guru) and my family friend Tim have both said that Dooku isn't using a fencing form in either movie. In ep2 the guy who played Dooku didn't learn it fast enough and in ep3 he wasnt using it on purpose. I believe my friend on fencing, he got 47th in the nation in fencing, so he knows a lot about it.

I cant tell how some1 fences so i wouldent know, i agree with either one of u depending on who has the best info.

Dooku may have been meant to be fencing in the movie, but he is not.

Originally posted by Admiral Akbar
i cant see the picture on that link, so im going to believe you until i see it.
He never sticked with it throughout the battle, he switched his styles dramatically, he was never alwayz in a defensive pose, he took offensive lead and cut back on the fencing at one point in the battle, so u are 50% correct.

What a poor excuse.....

Ok then, for those of you who don't have shitty computers, please tell him what the picture shows.

his belly gets slit.

yeah why dont you just post the pic? on imageshack theres a thing when you upload the image that says "hotlink for forums 1" copy that code into your post moron.

poor excuse, wtf are you talking about u homo, i cant acsess into that link, im not making this shit up.

And my comp is prolly better than whatever the hell u have sitting in your room and burning.

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
Dooku may have been meant to be fencing in the movie, but he is not.

Ok, well, i am glad your friend got fourty-whatever in fencing, but i have been studying star wars LSFighting knowledge for a while and i have studied Histories most worst and best forms of Swordplay. Most of the other forms are based on Samurai Swordplay, Bushido. And so are their outfits, being the fact that Star wars was based on a movie called "The Hidden Fortress" which was about Japanese Samurais trying to save a princess. One of the only forms that isn't Japanese-like is Makashi/Form II/ Way of the Ysalamir. On episode III, if you know Jack shit about fencing, you can clearly see his slow, power wielding attacks and defense are a clear distinct form of Fencing, which is his Form; Makashi.

he isn't fencing. he may have been meant to, but he simply is not. plus, the link wont post.

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
his belly gets slit.

THANK YOU! His abdomen is nowhere NEAR his head.

Get it?

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
he isn't fencing. he may have been meant to, but he simply is not. plus, the link wont post.

He "simply" is not?

No, he isn't, but as i told you before most forms are BASED on swordplay, meaning Gillard probably advanced it or changed it a bit. Either way, he WAS using the Form during the fight.

He attempts to fence, but he does it poorly, so its like not really fencing at all and its hard to tell. His lightsaber is just long enough to reach out into an area inches ahead of him, you cant determain if he uses it or not,
i believe he doesnt just becuz what starwars.com says. My friend has hyperspace and it u search dooku in rots it tells him what syles he used and so forth im not a member so i wouldent know.

Originally posted by Admiral Akbar
He attempts to fence, but he does it poorly, so its like not really fencing at all and its hard to tell. His lightsaber is just long enough to reach out into an area inches ahead of him, you cant determain if he uses it or not,
i believe he doesnt just becuz what starwars.com says. My friend has hyperspace and it u search dooku in rots it tells him what syles he used and so forth im not a member so i wouldent know.

He uses Form II in the movie. Anyone who knows the Forms can clearly see this!

And no, he doesn't attempt to fence, he attempts his hardest to kill Anakin using Form II, kay?

But form 2 is fencing. Therefor if he is not fencing, he cannot be using form 2. It's the same concept as this logic you love so much.

no, not really, he doesnt use form 2 throughout the entire battle, he changes, if they extended the friggin battle instead of cutting some of the battle scences out, we would see this, the book clearly says he changed styles, so im accepting what its telling me. Lucus made the battle scene longer when he wrote the scripts, in which Stover used some of the dialouges, and extra scenes that were not in the movie.

He doesnt use it, no more arguing

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
But form 2 is fencing. Therefor if he is not fencing, he cannot be using form 2. It's the same concept as this logic you love so much.

NO, NO, NO, NO, NO, NO, AND F*CKING NO!

Form II is NOT the exact replicate of Fencing! It is change, whether Advanced or below, it IS changed.

Watch Fencing and Form II. You WILL notice difference.

Dooku used Form II in Ep III.