tulak Hord vs. mace Windu

"In the fictional Star Wars universe, Tulak Hord was one of the Dark Lords of the Sith buried in the Valley of the Dark Lords on the planet Korriban. First featured in the video game Knights of the Old Republic, Tulak Hord was claimed by Kreia in the sequel game to be the greatest lightsaber duelist the Sith have ever known (at that time) and thus possibly the Sith's greatest lightsaber duelist ever. It is unknown what stance of lightsaber dueling Hord practiced, but the only other speculated successor in dueling skill would be Darth Tyranus or Luke Skywalker.

It has been rumoured the the Lightsaber form Hord used was a Pre-version of Form VII used by Mace Windu, a credit to his prowess as a saber duelist. Kreia also had mention that he had made a holocron of his fighting technique, something that Windu and other might have discovered."

That's not what I saw. Did you add that last paragraph?

thank yor that's what I heard

oops wrong spelling thank you

well i cant make my choice because we dont know much bout tulak but if he was said to be the greatest lightsaber duelist ever and its rumored that he fights with a pre-version of form 7 then............ im guessin he would win

windu

this is strange. I swear that that last paragraph wasnt there when I last went on wikipedia only a few minutes ago.

i saw that last paragraph somewhere dont remember if it was wikipedia but i saw it.............

(Now, with JanusEdit)

In the fictional Star Wars universe, Tulak Hord was one of the Dark Lords of the Sith buried in the Valley of the Dark Lords on the planet Korriban. (Fact)

First featured in the video game Knights of the Old Republic, Tulak Hord was claimed by Kreia in the sequel game to be the greatest lightsaber duelist the Sith have ever known (at that time) and thus possibly the Sith's greatest lightsaber duelist ever. (1st part-Fact; 2nd part- reasonable assessment)

It is unknown what stance of lightsaber dueling Hord practiced, but the only other speculated successor in dueling skill would be Darth Tyranus or Luke Skywalker.(Wild assumptions)

It has been rumoured the the Lightsaber form Hord used was a Pre-version of Form VII used by Mace Windu, a credit to his prowess as a saber duelist. (Where do these rumors arise from? Sounds suspicious)

Kreia also had mention that he had made a holocron of his fighting technique, something that Windu and other might have discovered." (So Windu found Tulak Hord's holocron? Did Revan just come back to known space and drop it?)

Nope. DIdn't add it.

Anyone else notice that that particular Wikipedia section was 1.5 parts fact and 3.5 parts speculation? For a grand total of 30% fact?

ya. I still think its better than nothing.

well, if I can get my story published and reconised by GL, you'll have a good deal better on Tulak Hord.

Originally posted by Darth_Janus
(Now, with JanusEdit)

In the fictional Star Wars universe, Tulak Hord was one of the Dark Lords of the Sith buried in the Valley of the Dark Lords on the planet Korriban. (Fact)

First featured in the video game Knights of the Old Republic, Tulak Hord was claimed by Kreia in the sequel game to be the greatest lightsaber duelist the Sith have ever known (at that time) and thus possibly the Sith's greatest lightsaber duelist ever. (1st part-Fact; 2nd part- reasonable assessment)

It is unknown what stance of lightsaber dueling Hord practiced, but the only other speculated successor in dueling skill would be Darth Tyranus or Luke Skywalker.(Wild assumptions)

It has been rumoured the the Lightsaber form Hord used was a Pre-version of Form VII used by Mace Windu, a credit to his prowess as a saber duelist. (Where do these rumors arise from? Sounds suspicious)

Kreia also had mention that he had made a holocron of his fighting technique, something that Windu and other might have discovered." (So Windu found Tulak Hord's holocron? Did Revan just come back to known space and drop it?)

This is a very solid assessment.

It is of my opinion that Tulak Hord is the superior duelist, if not because he was considered the best during a time when duelists were so common, you could probably bump into three of them on the way to the thrift store.

I am of the philosophical opinion that competition spurns development, and lack of it causes regression. Since Tulak existed in a time where lightsabers were more common than during the era of Mace Windu, I would have to give the match to the individual that could be mentioned as one of the greatest duelists ever.

right, when most of the sith used swords, there was more lightsabers

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
right, when most of the sith used swords, there was more lightsabers

Eh, swords charged with lightning, close enough.

Personally, it would seem to be a lot easier to wield an actual sword instead of the just the hilt, at least the counterbalance would be there.

ya, best lightsaber duelist, not best swords charged with lightning duelist

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
ya, best lightsaber duelist, not best swords charged with lightning duelist

Your objective is still to land a blow on your enemy, and use your weapon so to prevent them from landing a blow on you. The overall forms and methods wouldn't have changed all that much.

then why didnt Kreia say "best sword fighter"

Good question. She also says that Tulak Hord lived in a time of "Many great lightsaber duellists". Clearly he is after Sadow and the others... .right? Or is that possible?