Speculation: Who is R.A.B. ????? (Spoiler Alert)

Started by Quid Pro Quo31 pages

Speculation: Who is R.A.B. ????? (Spoiler Alert)

any ideas

Thats what I've been wondering! I was thinking of all the things we've had, and I think it must be someone new...

RAB could be Regulus A. Black, but hes dead

Originally posted by Phoenix
Thats what I've been wondering! I was thinking of all the things we've had, and I think it must be someone new...

RAB could be Regulus A. Black, but hes dead


It's Regulus Black. He exchanged the lockets before he died obviously.

Originally posted by TheSun
It's Regulus Black. He exchanged the lockets before he died obviously.

Thats a great guess , but you never know. JK's full of mysteries.Take the Half-Blood Prince , for example.

Originally posted by Hermione202
Thats a great guess , but you never know. JK's full of mysteries.Take the Half-Blood Prince , for example.

I never saw that coming to be honest.

Originally posted by TheSun
I never saw that coming to be honest.

me neither . I was just so suprised , when i read that part

Originally posted by Hermione202
me neither . I was just so suprised , when i read that part

I can't wait until Harry gets a piece of Snape.

Originally posted by Hermione202
me neither . I was just so suprised , when i read that part

Oh, I was on Veritaserum.com before that. They thought that Snape would be the HBP prince, so I can't say I wasn't all suprised.

Originally posted by TheSun
I can't wait until Harry gets a piece of Snape.

me neither.that will be a laugh 😂

Yeah, I'm still curious as to what side he's on and if there is something we don't know yet...

Originally posted by Elessea
Yeah, I'm still curious as to what side he's on and if there is something we don't know yet...

I pretty much think he's a baddie now you know. After killing the main defender of the good side and all...

Originally posted by TheSun
I pretty much think he's a baddie now you know. After killing the main defender of the good side and all...

and making that unbreakable vow .

Yes, but there could be some reason that he had to do that we don't know yet, but in the end he's still on their side.

I mean, at the End Harry finally says that now that he doesnt have any adult parent-like figure worrying about him (aka: James, Lily, Dumbledore, Sirius are all gone) he can go off and defeat Voldemort. It gives him a reason to leave school and therefore move on to bigger and more important things. So perhaps Snape knew he had to kill Dumbledore in order to give Harry the strength to defeat Voldemort...

no , i don't think so.Snpe is plain evil! Harry still had the Weasleys and Lupin

snae needs a crucio any one else wondering if he was acting under the imperious?

I wondered that to but then i remembered what DD said about why he trusts Snape.
he said he trusts Snape because 'Sanpe said he was sorry James and Lily died.'

how could DD believe that?

Look at this quote:

Spoiler:
"And Harry saw very clearly as he sat there under the hot sun how people who cared about him had stood in front of him one by one, his mother, his father, his godfather, and finally Dumbledore, all determined to protect him; but now that was over. He could not let anybody else stand between him and Voldemort; he must abandon forever the illusion he ought to have lost at the age of one, that the shelter of a parent's arms meant that nothing could hurt him. There was no waking from this nightmare, no comforting whisper in the dark that he was safe really, that it was all in his imagination; the last and greatest of his protectors had died, and he was more along than he had ever been before." (p.645)

Now that his final protector (Dumbledore) has died, Harry is alone and only alone can he truely be strong enough to defeat Voldemort. He has to go on alone, and he could not do that until he no longer had the protection of Dumbledore and the others. I think his death was eminent and necessary to the continuation and completion of the series.

WIth his protectors gone i rekon he will join them in book seven if you kno wot i mean

That may be the case, but I think as long as Dumbledore was alive Harry wouldn't have found the courage or strength to defeat Voldemort...he HAS to do it ALONE

It was never going to be as simple as driving a stake through his heart.