Qui-Gon Jin Vs Cin Drallig

atlant80, I read your story a while ago and just commented on it. It's good for a first write. Keep it up.

I'll get the proof later.

thx am i a noob i care very much for your answer D G

sweet, you are the first person to abreviate my name.

according to my sources, Cin was only 50. He was born in 69 B.B.Y. and is killed in 19 B.B.Y.

I just fixed the Wikipeda article on Cin. Some idiot claimed that Anakin killed him and was a much better duelist...yeah right.

That "idiot" is me. Go watch the movie again, he kills him. The game is wrong. For death scenes it has Anakin beat Mace in a fair fight and GG get stabbed. That's crap.

Anakin directy kills Cin and his students Bene and Whie at one time. Serra was killed at some other time.

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
That "idiot" is me. Go watch the movie again, he kills him. The game is wrong. For death scenes it has Anakin beat Mace in a fair fight and GG get stabbed. That's crap.

Anakin directy kills Cin and his students Bene and Whie at one time. Serra was killed at some other time.

Where was this? All I saw was a blurry 2 second hologram of Anakin fighting two people than it switched to him kneeling before Palps.

Go watch it again. You aren't parying enough attention or something.

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
Go watch it again. You aren't parying enough attention or something.

No, this is novelisation crap, Glentract. I watched that hologram many times. All it shows is Anakin manually choking some helpless young girl while trading two casual blows with what appears to be Cin Drallig. It also doesn't show whether or not there's an assload of Clone Troopers running around the place, shooting up jedi while they are engaged with Anakin.

You all seem to forget that at this point he IS officially a Sith (If in name only) and playing fair is never in their best interests. I find it unlikely that in a neutral, calm setting, one on one, that Anakin could beat Cin Drallig, or perhaps Jorus or that one jedi master idiot from Jedi Trial.

And there's nothing that indicates otherwise; just some two to three second hologram.

Glentract, I don't know where you're getting that from. . .

And does "on or slightly below Plo Koon's level" sound like something from an official source? Face it; Wiki cannot be trusted to the extent that you and ESB do.

I said in an earlier post(proving you didn't read all the previous post before posting) that although I think wikipedia is crap, it can be used to some degree. This was what that guy was going on so I used it to prove my point.

To some degree. But not to the point that you're using it. It can be used to find general info. But the little details need to be cross-referenced.

And maybe I missed a point in all this staggering bull. . . So what? Doesn't seem like you know what you're talking about to the greatest extent yourself.

Oddly enough the refernce it has for Revan is pretty accuret.

a lot of it is okay. The guy was saying things like he was the first to become a force ghost and such, so I started saying wikipedia stuff because I couldn't find anything else on him and he seems like the kind of guy who listens to it.

Sorry to bring this up again, but I thought some of the fanboys need this brought to their attention.

Direct quote, Pg. 377-378, Star Wars Episode 3 Novelisation

"Stone-faced, Obi-wan watched the younglings run into the room, fleeing a storm of blasterfire; he wateched as Cin Drallig and a pair of teenage padawans-was that Whie, the boy Yoda had brought to Vjun?- backing into the scene, blades whirling, cutting down the advancing clone troopers with deflected blaster bolts.
He watched a lightsaber blade flick into the shot, cutting down first one Padawan, then the other. He watched the brisk stride of a caped figure who hacked through Dralligs shoulder, then stood aside as the old Troll fell dying to let the rest of the clones blast the children to shreds."

That is directly from the ep3 book. If you don't believe me, go look. Page 377, near the botton is where it begins and then continues onto page 378. Drallig was killed by Anakin with little difficulty.

I think that this shows that Qui-gon is better because of how fast Drallig fell to Anakin. It was obviously not any luck on Anakin's part.

Hm. Novelization. Where Anakin and Dooku throw freakin' tables around the room. . . It's not worth anything, only the author's opinion. That even contradicts the movie, for Cin and Anakin are engaged in a duel in the holo-recording shown in ROTS.

I don't see how that contradicts the movie. It just goes into greater detail of the fight shown in the holorecording. That duel in the game it what never happened.

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
I don't see how that contradicts the movie. It just goes into greater detail of the fight shown in the holorecording. That duel in the game it what never happened.

It does contradict the movie. In the movie, Obi-Wan never saw a killing stroke on Cin, in the novelization, Obi-Wan saw Anakin kill several individuals including Cin.

Ergo, contradiction, and the novelization's take becomes crap.

And you just contradicted your own excerpt. . . Funny, the movie never shows the girl getting sabered, or Cin getting killed from behind. It's crap.

Originally posted by Darth Faunus
And you just contradicted your own excerpt. . . Funny, the movie never shows the girl getting sabered, or Cin getting killed from behind. It's crap.

Indeed. For all we know, they both escaped and they were hiding in the Millenium Falcon for all three OT Movies.

Originally posted by Sorgo
Indeed. For all we know, they both escaped and they were hiding in the Millenium Falcon for all three OT Movies.

So THAT'S why it was always breaking down.