ROTS Obi-Wan vs. ROTS Mace Windu

Obi-Wan's Form III vs. Mace's Form VII Vaapad. But how much of an advantage would Windu's Vaapad have against a Light Side opponent like Obi-Wan? Which great fighter comes out the victor and explain why you think so.

i don't really like this 1 cause every1 always hates on obi-wan 4 no reason but this 1 i think mace wins but it'll b a tough fight obi-wan never gives in easily

i think so because obi-wans style is to defensive and windu is so prefect at his that he can't find 2 many times where windu messes up so he can strike

This is ridiculous. Of course Mace owns Obi.

Let me halp you with your logic, you dont strike when your defending. Also, mace's Vaapad works on both lightside and dark side, according to Fishy (ty).

ANd obi wan gets owned because mace is far more advanced in lightsaber skills, take the obi wan vs dooku fight for instance. Obi wan was owned pretty badly, and mace could hold of dooku for a long time, maybe even win.

Not to mention this has been done before.

agree with fishy, i do

Obi-Wan wins. Why didn't the council send Mace Windu because Obi-Wan's form III is clearly a better form against non darksiders then form VII.

Originally posted by Admiral Akbar
Let me halp you with your logic, you dont strike when your defending. Also, mace's Vaapad works on both lightside and dark side, according to Fishy (ty).

ANd obi wan gets owned because mace is far more advanced in lightsaber skills, take the obi wan vs dooku fight for instance. Obi wan was owned pretty badly, and mace could hold of dooku for a long time, maybe even win.

Does that mean anything? Mace would still own Obi easily... Mace is an far above average Jedi, Obi Wan is an average Jedi Master.... He wouldn't stand a chance.

If Obi Wan in ROTS would've mastered Form III, then Obi Wan would remain living...
Remember, it's known that a master of Form III is invincible.

However Mace would take this, his much more skilled, and his saber skills are greater.

A form III master is supposed to be invincible butt they aren't, and you have to remember they aren't really able to attack either.

Actually, I think they are.

They can't attack much, true. But they only die once they run out of strength, otherwise their invincible.

Well, Obi-Wan is far from average. And Mace wouldn't own him; of yes he would. But still, Obi-Wan iis one of the best duelists in the Order because of his Soresu master. Not once did someone get a lightsaber through to him in ROTS, and he fought Dooku, Grievous, and Anakin. Now Dooku threw him away like a rag doll, Grievous beat the crap out of him physically, and Anakin kicked/grappled with him a lot, but no one got a blade on him. Mace would do what Dooku did, but still.

I don't know, Dooku would have defeated him with a lightsaber as well. Obi Wan has not mastered his form yet. If he did he would become a lot better then he is in ROTS.

Originally posted by Darth Windu
Well, Obi-Wan is far from average. And Mace wouldn't own him; of yes he would. But still, Obi-Wan iis one of the best duelists in the Order because of his Soresu master. Not once did someone get a lightsaber through to him in ROTS, and he fought Dooku, Grievous, and Anakin. Now Dooku threw him away like a rag doll, Grievous beat the crap out of him physically, and Anakin kicked/grappled with him a lot, but no one got a blade on him. Mace would do what Dooku did, but still.

That doesn't mean a thing... But anyways, Mace has been a master longer than Obi-Wan... his Force mastery is doubtlessly greater. ANd besides, the real factor here is lightsaber combat. Obi-Wan had pretty much mastered form III by ROTS. However, it was not enough to allow him to get the advantage of Dooku in the beginning. The only reason Obi-Wan won against Grievous was because the general pushed the attack. And Anakin was defeated using pure defense. Now, Mace Windu (WHOSE VAAPAD STYLE IS NOT STRONG AGAINST DARK SIDERS... GET THAT OUT OF YOUR HEADS) has to master several styles in order to refine and create the final installment of Juyo. Meaning? He is not just keen on defense (And having a blaster bolt reflection technique similar to Form III) he has a superior offense, something Obi-Wan does not possess. In the end? Obi-Wan will tire himself out and Mace will defeat him, bar some unforseen accident. Odds in favor of Mace. Mace wins.

why do people think mace windu would lose????

Because people are a bunch of idiots and they have a hard time thinking.

oh ok 😄