Originally posted by ESB-1138
Setting: (Forgot this) The CIS meeting room where Anakin killed them on Mustafar.
Oh great...lets see:
None of the Sith Lords has the possibility to use the room as an advantage and they all need quite much room for fighting. At least Sidious will go down vs Mace. ROTS Obi-Wan would wipe the ground with Maul especially in that room because Maul won't be able to use his acrobatics and maybe not even his double-lightsaber.
Leaves Yoda and Dooku and Yoda has a natural advantage in small rooms because of his size and the quite unique Tràkata technique he knows (used that in ROTS vs the clones in front of the temple - turning the lightsaber off, dodging and switching it on and off sending the blade through the opponents body).
Means all 3 Sith are going down here. Jedi win.
Sidious I'm pretty sure would get defeated by Yoda.
Obi-Wan would defeat Maul.
Dooku and Mace...
Dooku could defeat Mace but it all comes down to who is the first to fall. If Yoda or Obi-Wan defeats Sidious/Maul then Dooku is out of luck. But if he can defeat Mace before Yoda/Obi-Wan defeats Sidious/Maul then he could assist and defeat Yoda.
But deciding on everyone's skill levels as shown in movies, books, and games I would have to say that Yoda would be able to defeat Sidious first unless Sidious tries to keep a distance. Obi-Wan will wait for Maul to make a mistake so their match depends.
But Dooku wouldn't be able to defeat Mace in time to stop Yoda from defeating Sidious so it would be Dooku vs. Mace & Yoda so Dooku would get defeated. If Obi-Wan hasn't already defeated Maul it would be Maul vs. Obi-Wan, Mace, & Yoda. So Jedi wins.
Mine was
Yoda vs. Sidious= Since Sidious can't use the field to his edge (Unless he uses the tables) Yoda has a very good chance of defeating Sidious then he did in ROTS.
Dooku vs. Mace= If were the two alone I would say Dooku would win but seeing as Mace seems to be better then Sidious, Dooku wouldn't defeat him in time to help Sidious.
If you have: Mace vs Sidious, Yoda vs Dooku, Obi-Wan vs Maul
Now really...Mace took Sidious in 30 seconds of a fair fight.
So Mace vs Sidious > Mace (first finished)
Then you have 3 Jedi vs 2 Sith > Jedi win.
If you put it in that way:
Yoda vs Sidious; Mace vs Dooku; Obi-Wan vs Maul:
Mace vs Dooku would be the longest fight and Obi-Wan + Yoda would both win their matches. Again: Jedi win
If you make it:
Yoda vs Maul; Mace vs Sidious, Obi-Wan vs Maul
> Jedi win
If you make it:
Yoda vs Sidious; Mace vs Maul, Obi-Wan vs Sidious
> Jedi win because Maul gets owned first.
See...it doesn't matter how you put them it will always result in Jedi winning this without casualties.