another reason is that luke wasnt the chosen one because there was also lea and they didnt need luke if he died there was still lea and plus obiwan would have trained her or even yoda because his time came once he trained luke not once he was that age so i still think that this is anakins because without luke there was still hope
Originally posted by Darth Nhilus
I have got the truth. Anakin did destroy vader. They are the 2 sides of him so one sith is down. Then in saving his son luke he destroys sidious ending the sith. It just took some of lukes help to do it. But anakin is the chosen one.
No, the Sith live on after that.
Originally posted by DarthMaul9123
another reason is that luke wasnt the chosen one because there was also lea and they didnt need luke if he died there was still lea and plus obiwan would have trained her or even yoda because his time came once he trained luke not once he was that age so i still think that this is anakins because without luke there was still hope
I'm sorry. I don't see a single punctuation in this entire post. So it must be clear you are not trying to convey a message; instead, you are trying to spew incoherent jargon.
Anakin is the chosen one if there is a prophecy, he was the individual that completed the task of destroying the then Sith. It doesn't matter that Luke is the catalyst, the prophecy stated that Anakin would destroy the Sith and he did.
Good, atleast you guys know anakin was the chosen one, up where live we constantly have debates who was the chosen one when clearly anakin was and he did destroy the sith. He destroyed vader from within then destroyed the emperor. Sith gone, balance brought to the force. Anakin is the chosen one, end of story.
Hm.
Let's try this:
Anakin is only the chosen one IF the prophecy is given by someone who was have explicit knowledge of the future. Since only a being who can see past, present, and future at once could have such knowledge, that being would exist OUTSIDE of time, meaning? The prophecy has to come from an external source, it cannot come from the jedi, Qui-Gon Jinn, or the Sith at all.
But since we don't know for certain if it is or isn't from such a godlike source, we can only conclude that Anakin conformed to the prophecy because of his choices. If you decide that this is not so, then you must say that in the realm of Star Wars, there is no free will. People are ultimately compelled to do their duty to the Force.
Originally posted by Darth_Janus
Hm.Let's try this:
Anakin is only the chosen one IF the prophecy is given by someone who was have explicit knowledge of the future. Since only a being who can see past, present, and future at once could have such knowledge, that being would exist OUTSIDE of time, meaning? The prophecy has to come from an external source, it cannot come from the jedi, Qui-Gon Jinn, or the Sith at all.
But since we don't know for certain if it is or isn't from such a godlike source, we can only conclude that Anakin conformed to the prophecy because of his choices. If you decide that this is not so, then you must say that in the realm of Star Wars, there is no free will. People are ultimately compelled to do their duty to the Force.
You could be right of course, the prophecy could have been created by something outside of time and outside of live, but if it was created by something like that (the force) then the prophecy is false and not completed at all.
For the force to be in balance it would have to have both light and dark, both sides of the force. Otherwise the force itself would not be in balance, and why would the force create a prophecy about balance that destroys balance?
So its far more logical that one Jedi made it, and probably not even anything specific just that one special Jedi would always show up and destroy the dark side.