Darth Maul vs. ROTJ Luke and ANH Obi-wan

If Luke took Qui-gon's place and TMP Obi-wan was subsituted for ANH Obi-wan could they defeat Darth Maul?

The Jedi. Obi doesn't fight well alongside other Jedi, but he could choke Maul while Luke duels him, or something, it wouldn't be much but it'd be enough. Some people would actually think Luke could do this alone.

The Jedi have this. Maul becomes a Sith burger.

I expected it to be closer than this. Obi-wan is pretty good and (although I think Luke alone could take Maul in a Dark Rage state) most people don't think Luke is very good.

Originally posted by darthsith19
The Jedi. Obi doesn't fight well alongside other Jedi, but he could choke Maul while Luke duels him, or something, it wouldn't be much but it'd be enough. Some people would actually think Luke could do this alone.

Why would Obi-Wan Kenobi, a jedi who follows the code, choke another living being with the Force?

He wouldn't but he should. Anywho, I think Luke could take Maul by Himself, but I really really want Maul to win.

That's what I think, that Luke alone could defeat Maul, but I was pretty sure I was the only one.

Originally posted by Darth_Janus
Why would Obi-Wan Kenobi, a jedi who follows the code, choke another living being with the Force?

Originally posted by darthsith19
Luke did. No one ever said a Jedi couldn't use Force Choke on people.

I don't recall Luke ever proclaiming that he followed the Jedi Code.

That's because he doesn't. And darthsith19, the jedi follow peace and harmony in the galaxy. Force choking is an aggressive and evil tactic. Luke should never have done such a thing in ROTJ. But he also almost slew his father out of hate, and later on he turned to the darkside for a time, so obviously he had a long way to go. Like Jabba said "Bah, he's no jeedai!"

And the idea that ROTJ Luke can take Maul? Please, convince me.

I've tried. I still think that Luke beat Vader fair and mech-vader beat Maul's clone. So Luke could beat Maul.

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
I've tried. I still think that Luke beat Vader fair and mech-vader beat Maul's clone. So Luke could beat Maul.

Vader had to stab himself to defeat Darth Maul.

Alot of people here understimate Maul because he was killed by a Padawan. Does everyone remember how he killed a Powerful Jedi Master?

Yeah, didn't he kill two of them?

ya, Maul killed one in shadow hunter and then another padawon tried to kill him, but was killed in process.

ANH Obi is the only challenge here for Maul, and I have no idea how he would stock up agaisnt Maul. He has to be a Form III master by then, and he could be far more powerful with the force. On the other hand he could have been doing nothing for 20 years in which case he would be weaker then he was in ROTS.

Still my guess is with Luke and Obi Wan, purely becuase of Obi Wan. Luke would get owned fast.

ANH obi could beat maul alone with luke maul is BBQ sith

Snap, I thought this was TPM Obi. 😛

Maul gets owned. Ridiculously owned.

That's because he doesn't. And darthsith19, the jedi follow peace and harmony in the galaxy. Force choking is an aggressive and evil tactic. Luke should never have done such a thing in ROTJ. But he also almost slew his father out of hate, and later on he turned to the darkside for a time, so obviously he had a long way to go. Like Jabba said "Bah, he's no jeedai!"
Well, I still say the Jedi, Obi could throw objects at Maul, then.

Hey Janus, who do you think would win between Maul and the Jedi?

In this fight?

Well, ANH Obi-Wan doesn't go all out on Vader, so his skill is sketchy at best. But if he aged anything like Yoda and Dooku, he would be considerable with his Form II mastery and experience, and he would dominate Maul on his own. ROTJ Luke, with his inexperience, is a weak link here, but he would probably work well with Obi-Wan, since they share a master-apprentice bond; it may have some reprocussions on their ability to work together in combat by sensing one another's actions through the force. Just watch the TPM Duel of Fates as Qui Gon Jinn feints and Obi-Wan is right on top of it with an overhead attack. Master-apprentice teams have an edge over other such teams in that regard.