Is Snape really evil?

Started by Hermione1226 pages

Is Snape really evil?

Is Snape really evil or did D. wanted snape to kill him?? I think this could be all part of a big plan D. planed with snape...but i'm not really sure...
I think D. knew he would die because of the potion and so he wanted snape to kill him and V. would now be sure that snape is throuth and through a death eater.....so snape would had a better chance to help harry....
But why did D. trust Snape until the end??? What had happened or what had snape done, that D. trust him so much??? I don't think D. could be so wrong about snape, or not??....What do you think??

Ps: i'm german....and not so good at english.........so there could be many mistakes at writing.....sry xD 😮 🙂

Who in the HP world is going to doubt Snape's loyalty to Voldemort now?

Certainly not Voldemort.

He is good! GOOD! GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOD! Anyway, there are already threads on this.

for those of you who read you would know he was good i mean come on its all a plan even hagrid said he saw snape and D arguing in the woods (am guessing am am probably right that d was telling him that he had to kill him if it came to that and snape was refusing) why do you think he got so ticked when harry called hima coward in the forest or whatever and even D was kind of begging him to do it inside the skool come now people yall can't be that naive to believe JK's lil bluff (come people thinka lil like sherlock holmes)

ano a hevy agree ppl ... its obvious...dont be controversial ...its pretty obvious....an easy to work out

Originally posted by dmoney
for those of you who read you would know he was good i mean come on its all a plan even hagrid said he saw snape and D arguing in the woods (am guessing am am probably right that d was telling him that he had to kill him if it came to that and snape was refusing) why do you think he got so ticked when harry called hima coward in the forest or whatever and even D was kind of begging him to do it inside the skool come now people yall can't be that naive to believe JK's lil bluff (come people thinka lil like sherlock holmes)
Thats already been figured out by me and some other people but glad you thought of it too.

SNAPE IS THE EVILEST SUMBITCH SINCE VOLDEMORT!!!

And there are already threads on this.....GAH!

Originally posted by Pielover666
SNAPE IS THE EVILEST SUMBITCH SINCE VOLDEMORT!!!

And there are already threads on this.....GAH!

GOOOOOOD!

EEEEEEVIIIIIIILLLLLLLL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

GOOOOD!

If something evil was good, we'd be in a paralell universe.

Then it looks like we are because Snape is good!

Buyt Snape isn't good, just like Harry and Hermionie aren't in love.

Snape is as good as the relationship between Harry and Ginny!

For those who failed to read the first chapter, Snape made the Unbreakable Vow to Draco's mother. Since Draco refused to kill Dumbledore, Snape had to do it or else he would die and would be of no use to the good guys dead. Yes, he killed Dumbledore and saved his own sorry ass, but he did it so he could still be an informant from Voldemort's inner circle. It's all for the greater good.

*is getting annoyed by the ones who don't pay attention to the details in the book*

Originally posted by The Phantom
Snape is as good as the relationship between Harry and Ginny!

Not much then 😂

we already have threads on this .

agreed, but he is Good.

Hes Evil , acctually , but i'm over with that .

same here. i no longer discuss it. but i had to come here and see why this was opened.

*wonders if Hermione202 actually read his post*