Is Snape really evil? · Harry Potter

Pielover666 Restricted

Originally posted by KingDubya
*wonders if Hermione202 actually read his post*

her post.

KingDubya Mainstream Indie Rocker

That was an emote. That means that I'm referring to myself in the third person. *thinks that Pielover666 is oblivious to the fact that he uses emotes correctly*

HorseRiderxoxo Magical

Snape is evil in the last book he killed Dumbledore! I know he made a unbreakable Vow. But he always sayd "Dark Lord" and only Death Eaters say that. And he dosnt kill Harry because Voldemort wants to kill him himself.

Clark.K Flash

Ya..i mean i agree he made the unbreakable vow and all and Dumbledore mite have asked snape to kill him, But y did snape have a look of pure disgust on his face just beofre he kill Dumbledore...was it casue he din want the death eaters to see the look of saddness on his face(im assuming he wuld look sad juss before he wuld kill Dumbledore since The Big D trusted him beyond others..that is if snape is actually good which i doubt)

The Phantom Angel of Music

Originally posted by HorseRiderxoxo
Snape is evil in the last book he killed Dumbledore! I know he made a unbreakable Vow. But he always sayd "Dark Lord" and only Death Eaters say that. And he dosnt kill Harry because Voldemort wants to kill him himself.

ANYONE CAN SAY DARK LORD DAMMIT! >.< People are blind.... BLIND!

KingDubya Mainstream Indie Rocker

Originally posted by HorseRiderxoxo
Snape is evil in the last book he killed Dumbledore! I know he made a unbreakable Vow. But he always sayd "Dark Lord" and only Death Eaters say that. And he dosnt kill Harry because Voldemort wants to kill him himself.

You have to remember that Snape WAS a Death Eater, so obviously it had become a habit after years of saying that. And the reason he doesn't want to kill Harry (revealed in book 3) is because James saved his life once. Snape followed the four (James, Sirius, Lupin, and Peter) into the Shrieking Shack, was seen by Lupin in werewolf form, and James rushed Snape out of there before Lupin could attack.

Originally posted by Clark.K
Ya..i mean i agree he made the unbreakable vow and all and Dumbledore mite have asked snape to kill him, But y did snape have a look of pure disgust on his face just beofre he kill Dumbledore...was it casue he din want the death eaters to see the look of saddness on his face(im assuming he wuld look sad juss before he wuld kill Dumbledore since The Big D trusted him beyond others..that is if snape is actually good which i doubt)

That was probably becuase he was disgusted at himself for having to kill the man who trusted him most. You're probably right that he was sad on the inside and didn't want to show it.

Originally posted by The Phantom
ANYONE CAN SAY DARK LORD DAMMIT! >.< People are blind.... BLIND!

Very true Phantom, very true...

HorseRiderxoxo Magical

but wonted voldemort kill snape if he is no longer a death eater likeif one of the death eaters betray him he would kill them

KingDubya Mainstream Indie Rocker

Originally posted by HorseRiderxoxo
but wonted voldemort kill snape if he is no longer a death eater likeif one of the death eaters betray him he would kill them

If you read the fifth book thoroughly, you'd know that Snape is a master at Legillimancy (keeping people out of your mind). Most likely he can keep Voldemort form finding out he is a traitor. That's why he is still alive after all this time.

div Senior Member

i agree i dont think snape is actually evil ..i think in the seventh book harry will confront snape and snape will confess it was all dumbledores plan

div Senior Member

also does anyone think that theres a possibillity that dumbledore will return to hogwarts.........................as a GHOST

KingDubya Mainstream Indie Rocker

Originally posted by div
also does anyone think that theres a possibillity that dumbledore will return to hogwarts.........................as a GHOST

Well, they already have a portrait up. Harry can probably talk to Dumbledore through that, since the portraits can talk and move. But there is a possibility of that happening.

div Senior Member

i think that would be really cool if dumbledore became a ghost....

The Phantom Angel of Music

No! Let him rest in peace! He finally gets to relax. Besides, people become a ghost because they fear death or something like that. DD was ready, he is gone for good.

Insomnia Minion

I don't know why Harry and Hermione aren't in love, it seems that JKR is postponing it till the last book, because you know. It's kinda obvious. Hermione is hawt hawt hawt! JKR would have asked for a different actress if she was supposed to be the unlovable geek the entire series...

Oh, and Snape is kinda evil. There was no reason for D. to die... Unless that was death poison after all, but V. wanted the thief alive, so I doubt that.

If D. could scoop the substance out into a glass, why didn't he just dump the glass, or drink it rectally? ...what?

Coonskin 13 Racoon

Snape=Good
Harry/Ginny=good
Harry/Hermione=definitly not gonna happen (just read the whole page)
Period. End of Story.

The Phantom Angel of Music

Originally posted by Insomnia
I don't know why Harry and Hermione aren't in love, it seems that JKR is postponing it till the last book, because you know. It's kinda obvious. Hermione is hawt hawt [b]hawt! JKR would have asked for a different actress if she was supposed to be the unlovable geek the entire series...
Oh, and Snape is kinda evil. There was no reason for D. to die... Unless that was death poison after all, but V. wanted the thief alive, so I doubt that.
If D. could scoop the substance out into a glass, why didn't he just dump the glass, or drink it rectally? ...what? [/B]

She started off as the unlovable geek... she changed... she probably can't get rid of her. And Harry shouldnt be going for looks. DD deserved to die.

Coonskin 13 Racoon

Originally posted by The Phantom
DD deserved to die.

WTF!? He may have planned to die but he didn't DESERVE to die!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I AM ANGRY ROAR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

The Phantom Angel of Music

You don't see it from my point of view. And it's just a book, chill out.

Insomnia Minion

Originally posted by The Phantom
She started off as the unlovable geek... she changed... she probably can't get rid of her. And Harry shouldnt be going for looks. DD deserved to die.

In the movies she started off damn fine, for a little kid. She's even more damn fine today.
*swoon*

DD already died. I never really liked the replacement anyway.

The Phantom Angel of Music

I meant the book DD, I liked Richard Harris, he was great. And because she looks "fine" she isn't playing the Hermione role well.