Originally posted by JuntaiACtaully without the Avengers being part of the history it'd have to be a different, but similar Egg, etc.
Just because its going to take good storytelling to not introduce the Avengers into JLA, doesn't change the fact that both events [the death of Crime Syndicate] and items[The Egg] that happened in JLA/Avengers have crossed into DC continuity.
Originally posted by WhirlysplattWell, then it's not canon for marvel without a doubt.
If its canon for one and involves the characters of the other it must be Christianity or Islam. Think of Marvel having not quite seen the light yet. 🙂
Originally posted by Juntai
Just because its going to take good storytelling to not introduce the Avengers into JLA, doesn't change the fact that both events [the death of Crime Syndicate] and items[The Egg] that happened in JLA/Avengers have crossed into DC continuity.
Good point ists Canon for all!
Originally posted by CreshoskWho's to say they're not a part of the history? All he said is he won't be showing Flashbacks that have Avengers in them. Doesn't mean they weren't there. He might not show flashbacks at all, he might not even discuss what happened in JLA/Avengers, but there is in fact multiple congruences between current JLA and JLA/Avengers. Nothing you say can change that.
ACtaully without the Avengers being part of the history it'd have to be a different, but similar Egg, etc.Well, then it's not canon for marvel without a doubt.
Originally posted by Juntai
Who's to say they're not a part of the history? All he said is he won't be showing Flashbacks that have Avengers in them. Doesn't mean they weren't there. He might not show flashbacks at all, he might not even discuss what happened in JLA/Avengers, but there is in fact multiple congruences between current JLA and JLA/Avengers. Nothing you say can change that.
and that really is the point! 🙂
Originally posted by JuntaiNo avengers, not canon.
Who's to say they're not a part of the history? All he said is he won't be showing Flashbacks that have Avengers in them. Doesn't mean they weren't there. He might not show flashbacks at all, he might not even discuss what happened in JLA/Avengers, but there is in fact multiple congruences between current JLA and JLA/Avengers. Nothing you say can change that.
Different story, though similar. Like an alternate world in marvel, similar elements. But different story.
Like I said, Marvel has never accepted JLA Avengers as canon. What one company does is canon for the other? What DC decides is canon is also canon for Marvel? Scraping the Barrel? Tell that to the DC fanboys. I see someone else has been converted and joined into their joygasm.
Until Marvel acknowledges it, it will only be canon for DC, not Marvel.
Originally posted by Creshosk
No, not really.If the avengers aren't being ommitted then it is a similar story, but not canon. It's a different egg though similar, is still not canon.
It's not canon in Marvel, and it's a different story in DC.
They aren't being omitted from the story. The flash backs involving the Avengers will not be shown due to financial complications. It wasn't said that they have been removed rom the story entirely. Your position is biased due to preference of Marvel. (N.B. I prefer marvel to D.C. so you cannot use that Argument)
And if marvel could come up with a mini that would be as financially beneficial as this will be to D.C., I'm sure they would use the story as well.
Originally posted by yahman
They aren't being omitted from the story. The flash backs involving the Avengers will not be shown due to financial complications. It wasn't said that they have been removed rom the story entirely. Your position is biased due to preference of Marvel. (N.B. I prefer marvel to D.C. so you cannot use that Argument)And if marvel could come up with a mini that would be as financially beneficial as this will be to D.C., I'm sure they would use the story as well.
Financially yes, but Marvel knows this will upset many fans due to the crap PIS plots Busiek wrote about. Galactus getting killed. Thor being dropped in one punch. Photon draining GL's Energy. She-Hulk beating the crap out of a Aquaman who has city lifting strength and Xavier like telepathy(According to some), Mortal Herc restraining Diana before Thor got KO'd....
Originally posted by Sentry
Financially yes, but Marvel knows this will upset many fans due to the crap PIS plots Busiek wrote about. Galactus getting killed. Thor being dropped in one punch. Photon draining GL's Energy. She-Hulk beating the crap out of a Aquaman who has city lifting strength and Xavier like telepathy(According to some), Mortal Herc restraining Diana before Thor got KO'd....
Supes beat up Thor, Wonderwoman beat up Herc, Lobo beat up the Shiar, Krona beat up Galactus after destroying countless universes, Metron is as powerful as an Elder. GL absobed a cosmic cube and toasted Photon and Hakeye got saved by the Flash. 🙂
Its canon 🙂
Originally posted by Sentry
Financially yes, but Marvel knows this will upset many fans due to the crap PIS plots Busiek wrote about. Galactus getting killed. Thor being dropped in one punch. Photon draining GL's Energy. She-Hulk beating the crap out of a Aquaman who has city lifting strength and Xavier like telepathy(According to some), Mortal Herc restraining Diana before Thor got KO'd....
Umm i really think that the D.C. characters where generally De Powered for the whole affair. Thor (B4 King Thor) was being Illustatred at a weak level by Jurgens. And Herc was in his Mortal form. Superman should have murdered this version of Thor, (Even Byrne's Superman would have murdered this version of Thor).
The Galactus Krona thing was just a plothole, that wasn't covered up verry well.