Plo Koon vs. Cin Drallig

And the hologram again proves nothing.

Originally posted by Deus Ex
And the hologram again proves nothing.

No it dosen't but it is for sure that his swordsmanship isn't all it's cracked up to be, Vader handled him with one hand while choking who I think was Sera Keto. Question: Why dosen't SW.com say anything of Cin Drallig?

It wasn't Sera. It was Bine(?) and Whin. He had already killed Sera, since nothing goes against what the game says on it.

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
It wasn't Sera. It was Bine(?) and Whin. He had already killed Sera, since nothing goes against what the game says on it.

Ahhh ok. I feel Plo Koon takes this cause SW.com at least made an effort to write about him. . .

Originally posted by Deus Ex
Either PM me the things you want changed on it or put a post in my sig gallery (Link is in my profile)

If you don't, I'm likely to forget. Anything you want though, just ask. Makes it easier to make a sig right the first time.

Better yet I will PM you. Ok?

Originally posted by ReverendMakashi
Ahhh ok. I feel Plo Koon takes this cause SW.com at least made an effort to write about him. . .

Yet, They dident give enough effort, still there is so much info left out. I dont even know why CIn Drallig exists.. he wasnt in Lucas's original scripts just added to the movie for some apparent reason.

Originally posted by Admiral Akbar
Yet, They dident give enough effort, still there is so much info left out. I dont even know why CIn Drallig exists.. he wasnt in Lucas's original scripts just added to the movie for some apparent reason.

Amen. Why all of a sudden do people think he is an uber saberman?

Probably because he's listed as one of the top Council swordsmen in LOE, for instance, and by NG himself (Who I still think is an egotistical bastard).

In any case, trading two blows with someone does not make you better than them. People are quick to defend Plo Koon, but not Cin. How does that work?

Well, Im not quick to respond for any of them, but what info do we have about CIn that would make him the better fighter? Im not nessasarily saying Plo Koon would win, but with all the facts presented to us, Plo KOon was much more involved.. he fought in the hyperspace wars and in the clone wars, I would think giving koon a chance at this is more reasonable than supporting a ancient master who just trained jedi. If he was so legendary he would be better than mace or perhaps better than whoever is under mace.

Read LOE. Dooku himself thought Cin Drallig to be a formidable swordsman. He didn't mention Plo Koon.

Dooku also said that People like shaak ti, and Ki adi would be better than GG, but GG bested both of them.

Sorry for asking but was it LOE? Lab of Evil?

lol...Yep. Labyrinth of Evil. Dooku was thinking of swordsmen who could overcome Grievious. Cin was on the list. Plo Koon wasn't.

True, but many people he mentioned that were on the lists were beaten by GG. So that cant be entirely accurate.

Originally posted by Deus Ex
lol...Yep. Labyrinth of Evil. Dooku was thinking of swordsmen who could overcome Grievious. Cin was on the list. Plo Koon wasn't.

Was Anakin? Notice Plo and Anakin use the same form. It may because of their fighting style. Even if it isn't Anakin defeated Cin, and Dooku didn't mention him, just like Plo Koon. That doesn't prove much, if anything.

Originally posted by Deus Ex
lol...Yep. Labyrinth of Evil. Dooku was thinking of swordsmen who could overcome Grievious. Cin was on the list. Plo Koon wasn't.

We can't base this off of Dooku's opinion. Dooku ain't no fool but look, Sidious thought Anakin Skywalker would grow to become the most powerful Sith Lord and look what happened. . .the infamous "Mustafar jump" totally fuhcked Sidious plans up.

Originally posted by Admiral Akbar
True, but many people he mentioned that were on the lists were beaten by GG. So that cant be entirely accurate.

Who was on the list who was beaten? I don't recall one.

And Glentract, Anakin was a considerable swordsman, but hadn't mastered the mental game. Dooku knew this. So did everyone else.

Mental game or not, he defeated Cin. Anakin wasn't on the list. It shows he was good, but what I am saying is that being on it doesn't prove Cin would just because Plo wasn't on it.

Originally posted by Darth_Glentract
Mental game or not, he defeated Cin. Anakin wasn't on the list. It shows he was good, but what I am saying is that being on it doesn't prove Cin would just because Plo wasn't on it.

Well, it's something besides the hologram, which is all you guys are basing your "Nay-saying" arguments off of... a two to three second hologram. None of you even consider the situation. This isn't Cin standing there, looking like a samurai and Anakin standing opposite. They fight. Anakin easily wins. This is totally chaos, troopers everywhere, the jedi under siege.

Originally posted by ReverendMakashi
Ahhh ok. I feel Plo Koon takes this cause SW.com at least made an effort to write about him. . .

This right here is either a joke or the worst excuse to vote for Koon ever.