September's Debate - IS Harry A Horcrux?

Originally posted by Saratn
ok. Harry isn't a Horcrux, not even his scar for crying out loud. ok, just had to get that off my chest.

If Harry or his scar is a Horcrux, why did the Dark Lord try to kill him so many times? And why would he put a Horcrux in him, when he is so close to Dumbledore?

In a mugglecast episode they talked about how voldemort might of made harry a horcrux unknowingly

Originally posted by Fwiw187
Harry being a horcrux makes perfect sense... Ok if harry kills voldie then he is still alive cuz he is part of harry. If vldie kills harry he loses part of his soul( which he wouldn't care about) then the one who could kill him is dead and he will live again

Why are so many people spouting this claptrap as if it ws some sort of intelligent and insightful view? The whole concept ois logically flawed.

As I say, the only chance Voldemort had to do this was at the end of GoF.

Why did this debate begin on the 20th?

It may seem unlikely, but the author is certain to attempt some kind of a shocking twist.

okay this whole concept doesn't any sense at all. harry can't be a horcrux cause the dark lord went to his parents house meaning to kill him. he wouldn't have been able to make harry a horcux in sny of that time period much less later.

dont forget about what dumbledore thought.... dident he make a horcrux out of the 4 comon rooms, made from an object that was once, hufflepuffs, ravan claw, slithering "the ring", and griffindor, and the fifth was tom riddles book....

so how is harry one???

harry is the hero of the story line.. and the hero survives.... its simple, if harry is a horcrux then that means he will have to die in order to kill the dark lord... but that would be defeating the storyline... am i right... yall are thinking too hard on the subject.

this school hour is over see u tomarow....

id rather harry die... i love it wen the heros die

why does everyone want harry to die?!

I don't want to see Harry die... It just doesn't seem like that path the books would take. If they do, then I suppose I'll just accept it and move on...

i don't think harry is or was a horcruz but i think ddor was one in the end (i'm talking about the ring business. he only says that ring is no longer a horcrux but he (dumbledore)never said that he got rid of it)

well u have a point

well if harry dies that would like make the book series a complet failer... and JK would not sell as many books.. it would ruen the whole series..

o yeah while im here does any one know what the 7th books name is

??????!!!!

The only way harry can be a horcrux is for the horcrux to happen accidentally. You know like voldermort wanted to kill harry. he killed his parents instead and harry become a horcrux. otherwise... harry cant be a horcrux since voldermot wanted to kill harry in the begining. He didnt want to kill his parents just him. this means that it would have been useless to want to make harry a horcrux with the intent to kill him there and then. harry's relationship to voldermort is nothing but the scar. the snake as it says in the last book aint knowing that its a horcrux so the relationship cant be linked to the horcrux in any way. well thats all folks

it is Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince,
all of the ideas are pretty good too...

please ignore that last post i had made. i wasn't paying attention...

Voldemort had no time to do this 😛 And it would make no sense.

Ok at this poin everything is possible. What if when voldi tried to kill Harry as a baby he transfer one of his Horcrux to Harry unintentinally? And maybe that is another reason that Harry did not die as a baby. I think that because of the profecy that this theory does make some sense.

they say in the book it is varry hard to split a soul.... there is alomost no way voldi did it unantntionaly,, there is no way he did it at all