Magic Vs Power Cosmic

this has been discussed a bit before but its never had its own thread i dont think. ive always wondered about it. i know galactus doesnt really like magic because he doesnt understand it, and hes considered to be the embodyment of the power cosmic. are there any magic weilder out there who could take him on? the marvel universe seems to be based more on science than sourcery so i think the power cosmic is the way to go.

i DID THIS already Dam you
LOL

yeah, your the guy i just read talking about it in a different thread, so i wanted to see if any other people would actually discuss it and give some cool examples of fights between magic users and people who wield the power cosmic.

you mean i inspired you to create a thread 😊

The Power Cosmic is a force that can alter reality, allowing the user to do whatever he/she wants (including breaking the laws of physics) only being limited by how much cosmic energy the character can tap at a time. It seems to be part of the universe itself, and is mostly used by Cosmic Entities.

Magic also appears to be like a form of energy, except that it can defy the laws of physics naturally. However, it does have rules of its own to follow, which vary with the method of invocation, usually in the form of spoken spells. It appears to be present in everything, even living beings. All humans in the Marvel Universe have the ability to use magic, but only if properly trained. Most people are unaware that magic actually works. In addition, powerful magical beings from other dimensions have created specific, extremely powerful magical spells that they allow to be used (often indiscriminately) by those sorcerers who invoke their names. Every 100 years, a contest is held to elect the Sorcerer Supreme, whose job is to keep the universe safe from magical menaces. The current Sorcerer Supreme is Doctor Strange.

i have been thinking about it for a while and did a search and came across your stuff and i thought it deserved its own thread.

PEOPLE KEEP THIS THREAD ALIVE

Cosmic and mystical beings

Abrogate
Adam Warlock with Infinity Gauntlet
Agamotto
Ancient One
Anthos
Anti-Phoenix Force
Asgardian Destroyer
Astaroth
Astronomer
Atum
Blackheart
Beyonder - also called Kosmos, Cosmos and Maker
Captain Marvel
Captain Universe
Celestials - race
Caregiver
Champion
Chronos
Collector
Contemplator
Chthon
Cytorrak
Dark Gods
Death
Deviants - race
Dormammu
Dreamqueen
Ego the Living Planet
Elder Gods
Elders of the Universe - last of their race
Epiphany
Entropy
Eon
Epoch
Era
Eternals - race
Eternity
Explorer
Franklin Richards aka Psi-Lord
Gaia
Galactus
Grandmaster
Gardener
Goblin Force
Hawk God of Arcturus
Hyperstorm
Infiniti
Infinity
Judicator
King Thor
Korvak
Kubik
Living Tribunal
Lord Chaos
Maelstrom with Quantum Bands, Cosmic Awareness, and Anomaly's power; called "Supreme Maelstrom" by fans
Malevolence
Mangog
Master Order
Mephisto
Molecule Man
Monotheistic Gods
Nebula with Infinity Gauntlet
Nightmare
Nth Man
Numinus
Obliterator
Oblivion
One Above All
Onslaught
Origin
Pantheistic Gods
Possesor
Phoenix Force
Protege
Quasar
Runner
Satannish
Set the Serpent God
Shaper of Worlds
Silver Surfer
Spider-Man with the Uni-Power
the Stranger
Thanos with Heart of the Universe
Thanos with Infinity Gauntlet
The One Above All
Trader
Tyrant
Umar
Unbeing
Uni-Lord
Uni-Power
Valeria Von Doom aka Marvel Girl (II)
Void
Vortex
Voyd
The Watchers - a cosmic race
Wolverine with Crystal of Ultimate Vision
Yahweh
Zarathos

I always liked to think of "magic" as a force based on quantum mechanics, whereas cosmic power operates in a more classical fashion. Both can be utilized to achieve similar results; however, I would give the edge to magic because (based on how I'm defining it), it is not limited to the "common" physical laws.

BTW, isn't cosmic power/energy technically mostly protons and other subatomic particles moving close to lightspeed? Not that I wanna be a nit-picker here...

And what about psionics? Perhaps somewhere between the two? As much fun as discussing this stuff is, part of the problem lies in not knowing exactly what is meant when certain terms are used (ie, saying psionic is "mental" or "psychic" just skirts the issue).

psionics is kind a like mind of matter using your minds energy with conjuction of moving atoms IMO

saying mental or physic really isn't psionics in my opinion

Originally posted by Mindship
I always liked to think of "magic" as a force based on quantum mechanics, whereas cosmic power operates in a more classical fashion. Both can be utilized to achieve similar results; however, I would give the edge to magic because (based on how I'm defining it), it is not limited to the "common" physical laws.

BTW, isn't cosmic power/energy technically mostly protons and other subatomic particles moving close to lightspeed? Not that I wanna be a nit-picker here...

And what about psionics? Perhaps somewhere between the two? As much fun as discussing this stuff is, part of the problem lies in not knowing exactly what is meant when certain terms are used (ie, saying psionic is "mental" or "psychic" just skirts the issue).

Magic is also much greater than cosmic.

Originally posted by Juntai
Magic exists outside of quantum mechanics otherwise it would be broken down and utilized by people like Reed Richards or Lex Luthor, who already understand quantum physics..

Magic is also much greater than cosmic.

Maybe in DC but not in Marvel. The most powerful beings in Marvel, Phoenix and LT and the likes of the Infinites are all cosmic and would stomp any magic user.

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
Maybe in DC but not in Marvel. The most powerful beings in Marvel, Phoenix and LT and the likes of the Infinites are all cosmic and would stomp any magic user.

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
Maybe in DC but not in Marvel. The most powerful beings in Marvel, Phoenix and LT and the likes of the Infinites are all cosmic and would stomp any magic user.

Phoenix' original entry in Marvel Handbook said that she could generate any type of energy in any amount. I would assume that includes magic as well.

As far as the LT is concerned, I'm sure his power is both cosmic and magic. He interacts in dimensions that aren't bound by the laws of physics, dimensions where laws are based on magic instead.

So I think it all depends on where the user is, ie what type of dimension, what its fundamental laws are, etc.

Originally posted by Cosmic Flame
Phoenix' original entry in Marvel Handbook said that she could generate any type of energy in any amount. I would assume that includes magic as well.

As far as the LT is concerned, I'm sure his power is both cosmic and magic. He interacts in dimensions that aren't bound by the laws of physics, dimensions where laws are based on magic instead.

So I think it all depends on where the user is, ie what type of dimension, what its fundamental laws are, etc.

If it's true that Galactus IS power cosmic, then Magic wins.
Characters like Living tribunal are in a class of their own and should control ALL energies.

LT is cogik !!! cosmical magik !!!

Magical is devoid of any scientific reason at all. It follows no rules but it's own. It's like comparing a pencil to a pen. They both can do many of the same things, but lead is a completely different thing then ink.

Originally posted by Nataku8188
Magical is devoid of any scientific reason at all. It follows no rules but it's own. It's like comparing a pencil to a pen. They both can do many of the same things, but lead is a completely different thing then ink.

wrong as always tyrant....magic is energy but it vibrates and exists on higher levels .just like celestial tech....it follows principles but they are beyond our comprehension and non static.

Originally posted by RAGE17
wrong as always tyrant....magic is energy but it vibrates and exists on higher levels .just like celestial tech....it follows principles but they are beyond our comprehension and non static.

Either prove this or stop acting like a retard.