Carnage vs Storm

Originally posted by Tha C-Master
No, I'm not trying to change anyones opinion like you say I am, I am putting my points out and seeing if they counter it, thats what a debate is.

I think the match is close, you say storm wins, some say carnage wins, its not much of an argument in a theoretical debate.

I asked explicitly about the forcefield, and did NOT get an answer, so if I am assertively asking you your motives in hopes that you'll at least understand where I am coming from, then that is a good thing.

I don't try to make anyone believe anything, doesn't work too well, especially with fanboys lol. No offense either.

I get what you're saying.

No problem.

I still stand by my opinion that carnage has the crazy and the gib to gut Storm before she flies into space and destroys the planet with meteors and jazz.

And other claremont powers.

Hi swanky!!! Digging Aqua Team!!!

Oh my god, how is this *****, winning. I bet people just saying, she wins, because she is Black. I hate that garbage. carnage, has projectiles, and could take heavy amount of damage, and Storm, takes like a good moment, for the clouds to come out, and for her to attack. She would be dead by then.

Originally posted by Comic Book
Oh my god, how is this *****, winning. I bet people just saying, she wins, because she is Black. I hate that garbage. carnage, has projectiles, and could take heavy amount of damage, and Storm, takes like a good moment, for the clouds to come out, and for her to attack. She would be dead by then.

Thats a very ignorant view on Storm. X-men readers know that to be far from the case. Dont be fooled by the inaccurate cartoon portrayal of Storm. Comic book wise shes nothing like that.

I do read the x-men comic, and she still takes long. She gets tagged by, lady deathstrike, and almost died. This is Carnage, you know the man, that took down everybod at once, then they ganged up on him, to win. Carnage taken punishment in the past, and I see no problem on him taking this *****.

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
Thats a very ignorant view on Storm. X-men readers know that to be far from the case. Dont be fooled by the inaccurate cartoon portrayal of Storm. Comic book wise shes nothing like that.

Originally posted by Comic Book
I do read the x-men comic, and she still takes long. She gets tagged by, lady deathstrike, and almost died. This is Carnage, you know the man, that took down everybod at once, then they ganged up on him, to win. Carnage taken punishment in the past, and I see no problem on him taking this *****.

I mean there are better black, charaters, but i don't like it when thats the only reason, the character is over hyped. In the past she was good, but now her stories suck ass.

Originally posted by Comic Book
I do read the x-men comic, and she still takes long. She gets tagged by, lady deathstrike, and almost died. This is Carnage, you know the man, that took down everybod at once, then they ganged up on him, to win. Carnage taken punishment in the past, and I see no problem on him taking this *****.

Lets not get ahead of ourselves. I never placed my vote in this thread. I was just addressing the misconception that Storm takes an age to use any aspect of her weather powers. All regular X-men readers would know that all basic weather effects are virtually instantaneous. Whilst a hurricane manifests in seconds for example.

A moment to other people, but to Carnage, and his projectiles, it will seem like storm, takes a year and a day.

Good point, it isn't instantaneous, its virtually instantaneous, but it takes the speed of thought, and is only as strong as the earth's conditions.

Originally posted by Tha C-Master
Good point, it isn't instantaneous, its virtually instantaneous, but it takes the speed of thought, and is only as strong as the earth's conditions.

No. Its as strong as her strength of body and willpower. She can create a weather effect of any intensity that can occur within earths atmosphere naturally.

Originally posted by Comic Book
A moment to other people, but to Carnage, and his projectiles, it will seem like storm, takes a year and a day.

No merely a misconception.

unless, some one dies in front of her, or it's a really close match, I doubt her will power would start off strong at the begining, by the time she build up enough, she wil be dead. I mean, this isn't GL.

Originally posted by GalacticStorm
No. Its as strong as her strength of body and willpower. She can create a weather effect of any intensity that can occur within earths atmosphere naturally.

SHe controls the weather. I see what you mean though.

Originally posted by Comic Book
unless, some one dies in front of her, or it's a really close match, I doubt her will power would start off strong at the begining, by the time she build up enough, she wil be dead. I mean, this isn't GL.

😕

I mean, you get more will power, when you are loosing bad, but if your dead, then you can't get that fuel you need.

Originally posted by Comic Book
I mean, you get more will power, when you are loosing bad, but if your dead, then you can't get that fuel you need.

Your strength of will depends on various factors. All energy wielders' ability to pull off their highest feats depends on their strength of will. Dont see this as a potential weakness specific to Storm alone. Its just how it works. But during any given day she can still pull off any aspect of her powers.