ROTS Obi-Wan (Form IV) vs. General Grievous

We all know Obi-Wan can beat Grievous using form III but can he beat him when using Ataru?

wow nice thread. i think that he can not. He swiched for a reason. if he jumped GG would cut him to bits.

Just thought of the idea to and I agree with you 100% but I want to hear other people's opinions.

You can't make speculatory threads like this and expect a reasonable answer. I could just as easily say 'Grievous with Force Lighting and 10 arms versus a Six-foot tall Dark Side Yoda'.

What do you mean speculation Obi-Wan has used form IV before.

he used it when fighting maul, dooku, dooku in ROTS, and Anakin.

No he never used it against Dooku, correct me if I am wrong.

The why not put TPM Obi-Wan instead of 'Obi-Wan with Ataru'?

Youre wrong......lol

No he used it i think. he was jumping crazy. yet i may be wrong.

Originally posted by Darth Faunus
The why not put TPM Obi-Wan instead of 'Obi-Wan with Ataru'?

Because TPM Obi-Wan would be destroyed by Grievous and because we have seen ROTS Obi-Wan use Ataru.

Explain to me why a Soresu master would use Ataru. Obi-Wan doesn't use Ataru after TPM. Ever.

Actually if I remember correctly he used it against Anakin in ROTS.

Well, giving ground and not doing so much as a single flip throughout the entire duel doesn't seem very characteristic of an Ataru-user, does it.

Well Obi-Wan wasn't that conservative in that duel and that is not very characteristic of a Soresu user is it.

Uh, Soresu is not just how you swing your glowstick; it's a fighting philosophy. Obi-Wan was DEFENSIVE in his fight with Anakin. This is Soresu philosophy, not Ataru, which is OFFENSIVE.

Well...going offensive into the fight with Grievous, Obi-Wan would have force pushed him first instead of fighting him.

And considering the fact that TPM Obi-Wan with form IV was able to cut Maul's lightsaber into pieces and put Maul on his ass I'm pretty sure ROTS Obi-Wan using form IV would still kick Grievous.

Originally posted by Darth Faunus
Well, giving ground and not doing so much as a single flip throughout the entire duel doesn't seem very characteristic of an Ataru-user, does it.

Yet he gave ground like nothing else. Nothing reminiscent of his TPM form.

And spins and twists don't make you an Ataru practitioner, man. Did you not read what I wrote above, Jack?

Uh, Soresu is not just how you swing your glowstick; it's a fighting philosophy. Obi-Wan was DEFENSIVE in his fight with Anakin. This is Soresu philosophy, not Ataru, which is OFFENSIVE.

If you paid more attention to what I post you might not be wrong most of the time.