I'd give it to DareDevil.
Spiderman's spider-sense would allow him to avoid most assaults (thus providing him with a strong defensive ability), but he wouldnt be able to attack his foes.
Batman's cowl has several lenses (ranging from infra-red to ultra-violet to green-hue NV), however the room is totally dark thus the only lense that would be working would be the infra-red that operates off heat (the green-hue nightvision can see in the dark, but not in total darkness ....it needs at least some ambient light to amplify ...at least the standard military grade models do, thus Batman might have something better, but for now let's assume he has your current top-grade NV suite). Thus he only has his IR lenses working, and thus he can see EVERYONE perfectly. The only problem is that DD's billy-clubs do not have a heat signature, and thus he might be able to see DD throw-the clubs, but he won't see where the clubs were thrown. Bat's would probably the 3rd man standing (i.e 1) DD, 2) Spider, 3) Bats and/or Sabretooth), but he suffers from the inverse of Spiderman in that while spiderman has perfect defense in a darkroom but no offense, Batman has pretty good offense (due to IR enablement) but no way to defend against DD's projectiles.
Sabretooth has advanced sensory abilities, and would smell most of the folks in the room. Thus he has pretty good assault capability in total darkness since he can smell his foes. He also has eyes that can see very well in the dark, but since this is a totally dark room they will be useless (in much the same way as the NV lenses, animals that have good nightvision still require some ambient light for amplification. In TOTAL darkness a cat will see squat, but have some stars, or the slightest ambient light, in the sky and the cat's eyes will see very well). Anyways, Sabretooth can locate his foes (thus like Batman he has great attack capability, although while Bat's relies on IR STooth would rely on scent), but he also faces the same problem as Bats .....defense. He cannot smell DD's batons streaking towards his head! Thus he will be no 3 with Bats.
Captain America: Goes down. His shield is impenetrable, but if he cannot see/smell/sense it coming then he cannot block it. Thus DD's batons, Batman's batarangs, or STooth's claws will quickly take Steve out of this fight. Quick.
Punisher: Sadly he only has a handgun, and at that with no extra clips. He could try to shoot the room, but the standard handgun has between 6 (revolver) to 16 shots (high-clip pistol that is standard and not those extended clip versions). Thus, assuming the standard 9 shots for a pistol (and assuming one in the chamber to make 10), Castle would have it rough. For example even if he hit Sabretooth that wouldn't do anything to ST (a handgun versus Sabretooth is suicide). Spiderman would easily evade any bullets through his spidey-sense. Batman's IR lenses may not detect DareDevil's batons, but flying bullets are hot (and with IR lenses on the slugs would seem like tracer-rounds, and Bat's knows how to evade bullets quite well .....and thus 10 bullets wouldn't phase him much). And DD would sense the slugs EASY.
The only one who would be in ANY danger of getting shot is Captain America, and he could simply cower behind his shield the moment he hears the first gunshot.
Anyways, Frank Castle goes down hard and quick. He'd probably have DareDevil, Sabretooth, and Batman heading for him at the same time.
First to go down: Frank Castle.
Second to go down: Captain America (less than a minute after Frank)
Third to go down: Sabretooth or Batman
Next to go down: Spiderman
Last man standing: DareDevil .....this fight was made for him. In fact it is somewhat unfair to all the rest.
I'd say Spiderman takes DD more often than not. He won't be getting hit by much, even in total darkness. His sense allows him to detect the source of an attack pretty accurately. I'd say he can take out most of these guys by riposte alone. Sabes would a be a lot trickier. The only way I see him permenantly putting Creed down is if he gets a whole lot of webbing down Victor's throat. Which I don't see happening when he cannot see where he is aiming. Everyone but Spiderman and Sabretooth die, because Spiderman lacks the offensive capabilities to actually do the job, when blind and confined to a 15x15 room.
maybe Spidey could break out hte spider tracers he hasn't used in years and stick them to people when he finds them... that way he'll know exactly where everone is
the thing here is... with bloodlust on...DD steals Punisher's and Batman's weapons and Cap's shield....and he uses them to take out Sabretooth
Originally posted by Dizzle
Would that work? Sabretooth can take WAY more than a pistol. The shield's powerful, but Cap is both stronger and more skilled with it than DD. Neither has the physical strength to take out Sabes with it. Spiderman throwing the shield? Maybe. DD? No.
well it's not really a case of physical strength.... once DD KOs Cap, he steals the shield... and he doesn't need to be uber skilled with it if Sabes can't see it coming.... just keep whacking him in the temple, throat, groin, etc... with it... and as for the gun... again with Sabes being blind... he can go right up to him and shoot him through the eyes or throat... or groin
😄
Originally posted by Scoobless
well it's not really a case of physical strength.... once DD KOs Cap, he steals the shield... and he doesn't need to be uber skilled with it if Sabes can't see it coming.... just keep whacking him in the temple, throat, groin, etc... with it... and as for the gun... again with Sabes being blind... he can go right up to him and shoot him through the eyes or throat... or groin😄
What I'm saying is, Sabes will be laughing off bullets and shield strikes to the temple, throat, and groin. That sort of thing's actually WITHIN his powerset. Pressure points never work on him or Wolverine... If it's DD with a pistol and the shield vs. Sabretooth, Sabes still wins, even in pitch blackness.
Oh, and Spiderman needs (counts on fingers) ONE hit to rip off DD's head, when playing to his fullest. I really don't see Daredevil winning a majority, even in darkness.