Originally posted by Dizzle
Well, if we really want to get into it, Batman could very well have a flashlight, which would kill the point of having the fight in a black room. (hey, all detectives have flashlights... even the world's greatest)
Lighting up a flashlight would be suicide in a dark room. Everyone would know his position.
DD wins this 99% of the time. This fight was made for him. The guy can "see" 360 degrees and can detect where everyone is going with his radar.
First to fall: Punisher. Why only give him a handgun? Unless it's a high velocity pistol (in which case he would only have a small clip), noone in the room will be hurt. Sabretooth can survive from handgun shot. DD, Cap and Batman all have costumes that can take a shot from a pistol. Spidey will just jump out of the way. Punisher can't do anything in this situation.
Second: Captain America. Rogers won't be able to defend against himself from DD's blows.
Third: Sabretooth. His hearing and smell will give him a general area of where his ooponents are but not specific enough where he can strike accurate attacks.
Fourth: Batman. His infrared lenses will give him a huge advantage but as another reader pointed out, how won't be able to protect himself against projectiles...however...there is a way he can win it over daredevil (more on that lateR).
Fifth: Spiderman. How is spiderman going to land blows against DD? His spidersense will tell him if MAtt's about to attack him, but the most spiderman could hope for is to just throw a wild kick or punch and hope it'll strike DD. DD would probably counter it anyway.
Alternative victory: Batman. If I was trapped in a dark room with batman's utility belt and his infrared lenses I would do this:
1) Switch my mask to block all noises.
2) Switch on infrared lenses
3) Put on portable gas mask
4) Close my eyes and throw all my flashbangs and tear gas pellets into the room. The Flashbangs will incapacitate everyone's hearing and balance. The gas pellets will keep people distorted even more.
5) While in infrared mode, pluck off everyone with batarangs and explosives.