wow, dont get your panties in a bunch there pal. there's no use for yelling.
basically heres how it works. some people love the OT and hate the PT and some people love both.
your not going to convince any of us who do like the PT to not like it, so dont bother trying.
you seem however to be unable to look at everything as a whole and not compare the PT to the OT. which is a shame, because they are supposed to be different, different characters (for the most part) at a different time, as well a different generation of movie goers. the OT is a classic and will be loved for ever, and the PT was an amazing trilogy that showed the darker more serious side to SW, politics, the sith, lightsaber fights that dont suck. it also showed us why the jedi knights were the guardians of peace and justice, and how they fell. most importantly it showed us how a young innocent boy turned into the evil killing machine the world loves.
you may hate it, but I dont, and your not going to convince me of anything else, nor will you convince anyone else who loves the PT.
so just give it a rest
you missed a word in your sentence
"but as you didnt understand i was speaking you as if you were"
?
at any rate your refusing to even listen to what I have to say means i will give equal respect to what you have to say. I dont have time to listen to noobs who are so single minded that they refuse to even read what other people have to say.
A New Hope was a pretty good and interesting movie in my opinion. 🙂
The Tantive V (or whatever) scene was good directing on GL's part.
And as the first glance of Vader it was done perfectly with him entering the ship, picking up a guy with one hand and shaking him to death and even without poor acting.
The death star scenes were good directed with great acting of Leia, Luke and Han screaming at each other in the trash compactor.
The first glimpse to the dark side couldn't have been better with the 'Force' choke, that part was absolutely genius.
The plot and climax were pretty original and good too.
Of course a lot was spoiled by the other movies with suddenly focusing on the flashier aspects of the SW universe like the duels but as ANH is the most 'star wars' as in battle in space as main focus it is actually a very good script. (although the rough draft was the best)
And especially the acting is good in that movie.. The characters portrayed by the actors seemed really natural in the SW galaxy.. Something wich was hardly the case in the PT.
But I think it's wrong to compare ANH with the prequels as the prequels mainly have the constant special effects going for them.
But as for AotC.. That movies whole plot is just a little off.. And caring about characters never really held me busy with boring people like Obi Wan.
I only watch it because it looks nice and is Star Wars.
Originally posted by overlordtrue true. That's why I watched it. But only once. And I saw ROTS once but that's new.
A New Hope was a pretty good and interesting movie in my opinion. 🙂The Tantive V (or whatever) scene was good directing on GL's part.
And as the first glance of Vader it was done perfectly with him entering the ship, picking up a guy with one hand and shaking him to death and even without poor acting.The death star scenes were good directed with great acting of Leia, Luke and Han screaming at each other in the trash compactor.
The first glimpse to the dark side couldn't have been better with the 'Force' choke, that part was absolutely genius.The plot and climax were pretty original and good too.
Of course a lot was spoiled by the other movies with suddenly focusing on the flashier aspects of the SW universe like the duels but as ANH is the most 'star wars' as in battle in space as main focus it is actually a very good script. (although the rough draft was the best)
And especially the acting is good in that movie.. The characters portrayed by the actors seemed really natural in the SW galaxy.. Something wich was hardly the case in the PT.
But I think it's wrong to compare ANH with the prequels as the prequels mainly have the constant special effects going for them.But as for AotC.. That movies whole plot is just a little off.. And caring about characters never really held me busy with boring people like Obi Wan.
I only watch it because it looks nice and is Star Wars.
The ending of AOTC just didn't make sence. The wedding was 2 seconds long then end credits. I was like WTF? What about the clone troopers and Count Dooku and all that? I didn't watch CW cause I don't like cartoons based on real movies.
I h8 AOTC! There.
So what? There's bad dialogue in every Star Wars movie, and there's excellent dialogue in every Star Wars movie. Why not give Lucas credit for when he writes the good stuff too? But no, you have more fun being Mr. Negative, always harranging on the clunky dialogue. I keep forgetting everything has to be perfect in your world.
Originally posted by chinabingYou again? Go cry somewhere else about criticism.
So what? There's bad dialogue in every Star Wars movie, and there's excellent dialogue in every Star Wars movie. Why not give Lucas credit for when he writes the good stuff too? But no, you have more fun being Mr. Negative, always harranging on the clunky dialogue. I keep forgetting everything has to be perfect in your world.
Why don't you go ask whether you can be moderator so you can close discussions where negative opinions shine through.
Or just get over it.
Originally posted by overlordchinabing got told 😂
You again? Go cry somewhere else about criticism.
This is a thread, we are here to discuss topics (though pretty stupid ones most of the time). I've said it a thousand times, I don't really have problems with the movies, I just happen to think some could've been better and I state the arguments.Why don't you go ask whether you can be moderator so you can close discussions where negative opinions shine through.
Or just get over it.