Brandon Routh or Christopher Reeve?

Reeve was always severely overrated in my opinion. I saw the first Superman I while back and remember thinking: "Man, THIS is the guy that everyone loves so much as Superman?!" And I still think that to a certain degree. I probably like Routh better as Superman. He fits the role better.

Originally posted by MattDay
c'mon guys move on, he's here, reeve died, change with the times

Just because Routh is still alive doesnt make him any better... 😬

and maybe someone should tell singer to change with the times... he might make a more modern superman then... 😬

Its a close one. both are fantastic. Routh looks more like superman does in the comics compared to Reeves if you look at him feature by feature. He could beef up a little more, especially around neck and the arms, just to make him look a bit more..............GRRR and ........ butch.
As far as acting's concerned, Routh was just as good as Reeves and every bit as believable as a man of steel.

i liked how Routh played clark kent better coz he wasn't as dorky and Routh is just HOT!!! 😍

Well..I.........erm......suppose I agree. From a hetero male's point of view of course.

Originally posted by phreak_v2.o
i liked how Routh played clark kent better coz he wasn't as dorky and Routh is just HOT!!! 😍

Clark Kent is suppose to be dorky tho...so?