X-men 3 Vs Superman Returns

Originally posted by Blair Wind
saw the trailer for supers.....i wasnt really impressed....

indeed

X3 for both....out of loyalty..and the fact that I don't really like Superman very much...plus they just seem far too smug about the Superman movie than the X-Men one...and the Superman they've got annoys me...

Superman will be better..

X3 has too many characters. The plot is going to be terribly mired..

Though Bryan Singer is a great director, I think the new Superman looks terrible. This actor just doesn't come off as Superman to me.

X3, however, looks really good. I'm looking forward to Kelsey Grammer's take on Beast. And I'm crossing my fingers for Iceman learning how to cover his body in ice.

Just saw a black and white pic of Kelsey Grammer as the beast in the paper, looking beasty, want to see it in colour though, wonder if he's the same shade of blue as Mystique!

OMFG...just saw the X3 trailer...it looks simply put... out of this world. Besides i hate Superman, i hate the traitor Brian Singer and i hate the superman trailer. so i guess i'm looking more forward to X3

I want to see X3 more, but Superman will make more money in the box office.

Judging from the following trailers, X3 looks way more impressive than Superman Returns.

I hope Brian Singer made the right choice, and I am looking forward to Superman Returns, but the X3 trailer is kick-ass compared to the Superman Returns trailer.

Superman Returns:
http://supermanreturns.warnerbros.com/trailer.html

X3:
http://www.apple.com/trailers/fox/x3/

Thoughts?

Not really much to compare. We only saw sets and brief glimpses at Superman's childhood. That's it. X-Men 3 was much more indepth and actually revealed a plot. Superman was a teaser. X-Men was a preview.

But I think Superman Returns will suck because of that ghastly costume....

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f43/t379490.html 😐

Originally posted by Harvey Dent
Judging from the following trailers, X3 looks way more impressive than Superman Returns.

Thoughts?

Bryan Singer is an excellent director. It should really say something that James Marsden (Cyclops) was so impressed with him, that he practically abandoned his X-Men contract to work on Superman Returns.

Brett Ratner is the man who has given us Rush Hour and Rush Hour 2.

I couldn't say which will do better, but I confidentally expect Superman to have the better story, filming, depth, and acting. Not that the returning X-Men cast aren't all gifted actors, but I believe it takes a good director to bring out a good performance in the cast.

Vinnie Jones isn't a gifted actor. I understand that any English man with basic motor skills and a voice has the ability to impress an American audience, but he's actually lame.

Now I've seen him as Juggernaut, I laugh.

The reason shit films fill cinemas and why so many comic book movies ARE shit is because stupid fanboy idiots make them hits at the box office out of loyalty instead of seeing that trailer, not being impressed by quick cuts of the action scenes and going "Wait...going to be shit isn't it?"

-AC

mite b sentinals in dis?

Both will kickass, looking forward to both.

indeed i am lookign forward to Superman. But also i would like to see how X-men will be like.

It seems like that both movies will be the must watch of Summer

The X3 trailer was terrible. Way to go...slapping a long, drawn out, boring monologue over way too many different images. It makes the trailer nearly incoherent and completely intolerable.

While this has been stated before, I'll say it again. Singer specifically said that the Superman Returns trailer was not meant to "wow" people, just to let them know the movie was being made, he didn't make it flashy because he didn't want to show footage he fealt was not ready to be shown, he also stated that future trailers would have much more dialogue and more action.

Personally I think Superman Returns will out-gross X3 by a landslide, but I could care less, I'm looking forward to both immensly.

Im looking foward to both as well but I'd have to say that x-men teaser was kinda kick ass over Superman Returns teaser and revealed alot more too. I didn't know archangel was in it till i saw it today. I thought I saw Juggs too, which is whom i'd mostly looked foward to seeing. I thought he was gonna be CGI. And the Beast, lol i duno, i may get used to the look, but we'll see.

Betting both will be disappointing, but X3 will be the better of the two.