Rage.Of.Olympus
Senior Member
Originally posted by carver9
I'm not trying to be fickle (whatever that means), I'm trying to get you to understand what I am talking about.When has a high herald defeated beings like thor recently defeated? I never said that thor should be a skyfather but what I did say is that in my eyes, he is above high herald and again, that is due to resent feats.
Low trans is good enough for me.
Look, a single or even a hand few of showings does not change a character's status. It takes more than that. At least outside of a direct upgrade. Or a crucial defeat. I.e. Thor overpowering say the Hulk. That might change his standing. Or simply have more gammatards enact their vengeance.
No matter what happens, Thor will almost surely be one of Marvel's most premier heroes.
Hey, I'm arguably the biggest Thor fan on the board, I'd love for Thor to be written as nigh unstoppable (Captain America and Hulk fans have got it good currently) but it's just not happening. For Thor's status to change, he'd have to be written at Glory beating levels across the board. Not by a single writer.
Originally posted by CosmicComet
He's not being fickle. Never once did Carver say during Thor's rougher spots (which, imo, aren't over yet so long as Pak remains), that he's no longer a Thor fan. All he said was truth; that writers can and do influence powerlevels greatly and that there is no arguing with their established status quo with past feats when all that matters is the now.I remember him lamenting but accepting that Thor was being written so weak, nothing more.
GTFO. Carver's one of the most fickle posters I know. He argued Beta Ray Bill was beyond Thor after he read Stormbreaker. All it takes is 1 good showing to completely change his mind.
No offense of course, I like Carver.
