"what if" superman runs the gauntlet

the author of the thread said that galactus can't take the pc back in this thread or it would be kinda useless. seriously its not fanboyism theres is a chance not the best chance but a chance considering Dr. Strange beat Galactus. and this would be a faster stronger more powerful Dr. Strange w/ PC abilities..

^ No, he didn't. Check the start of the thread.

He said it on page 2 or 3, I think.

To be honest, that's kinda bogus. I mean, you can't start a thread like this and then alter the rules later on. That would be like starting a Aunt May vs Galactus, then two pages later saying that she gained Dormammu's powers. That's just desperation.

well what's the point of a power if ur opponent can take it back any second. its not much of a fight then.

Originally posted by Marcus4600
To be honest, that's kinda bogus. I mean, you can't start a thread like this and then alter the rules later on. That would be like starting a Aunt May vs Galactus, then two pages later saying that she gained Dormammu's powers. That's just desperation.

My only problem is that limiting one oponent to a certain use of his abilities. It would be like if you took your Wolverine vs Slade thread, and then out of nowhere said that Wolverine can't use his claws. It's just killing it. Also, with the abilities of Dr. Strange, he doesn't need the Power Cosmic anyway, so it's still a good fight.

"What if" Clark would run the table....quite easily, in fact. 😬

This version of Superman can defeat Spectre....

you're basically having Silver Surfer, Superman, and Dr. Strange merged into one person fighting all these guys.

Originally posted by Marcus4600
My only problem is that limiting one oponent to a certain use of his abilities. It would be like if you took your Wolverine vs Slade thread, and then out of nowhere said that Wolverine can't use his claws. It's just killing it. Also, with the abilities of Dr. Strange, he doesn't need the Power Cosmic anyway, so it's still a good fight.