Originally posted by bench261
depends what kinda badguys r in the city...most of batmans enemies in gotham are non powered humans like him...except his has teh advantage of money, gadgets, and information along with element of surprise and planning. on top of that he's in better shape than most of his opponents. with the exception of low level brutes like clay face or bane..which spiderman can easily out smart or over power.
spider-man's enemies are usually stronger than he is, or at the very least as strong. so the strength is negated and he has to outsmart them as well. if a killer like carnage was on the loose, i'd rather have spider-man be in the city...joker, 2face, penguin, riddler, n madhatter really wouldnt scare me. realistically the police or army can kill them by brute force or by numbers..but they're usually inept in comics.
i think spiderman would fit in both cities since it's like a step down, batman would have more of a challenge fighting spidy's enemies. i'm sure he can do it. but the vast majority is stronger or deadlier than clayface or bane.
so it's pretty much on thugs vs super powered villains. in real life i'd worry more about a real carnage or venom than a real mad hatter/joker or mob boss.
So true.
lots of batman fans i see....
spidey would handle gotham a lot better than batman would handle new york.
the main reason batman has such control over gotham is because he spent his entire life and dark business there.
did batman ever have to defend gotham against beings like firelord?
besides, considering this is a race... spidey just really moves faster than batman... and that's not in a litteral sense.
Batman is knows his city well enough to even guess what he going to face each night. He doesn't get allot of powerhouses but as it has been proven before batman always as an escape plan or some device inside his suit.
If batman were to switch cities to New York, then his thinking is going to change instead of just wearing he regular suites he is going to start shelling out his specialized suites. And with the stuff that batman is going to bring out (stuff that he is suppose to have) it is going to be spidy's villians who would need plot devices to get to him.
And with that said batman is going to have an easy time cleaning out spiderman's city.
Originally posted by lifeisaglich
Batman is knows his city well enough to even guess what he going to face each night. He doesn't get allot of powerhouses but as it has been proven before batman always as an escape plan or some device inside his suit.If batman were to switch cities to New York, then his thinking is going to change instead of just wearing he regular suites he is going to start shelling out his specialized suites. And with the stuff that batman is going to bring out (stuff that he is suppose to have) it is going to be spidy's villians who would need plot devices to get to him.
And with that said batman is going to have an easy time cleaning out spiderman's city.
batman is outgunned, realistically if he doesnt get killed in their first encounter with spidy's enemies. 2nd or 3rd encounter after he sulks and broods in his batcave comin up with sum device..then he could win
venom or carnage have better ninja skills as in stealth, climbing and movin from buildin to buildin. superior strength and durability. if venom webbed batman in the face, batman would suffocate and die....he has no strength to rip it off. h2h would get batman's bones crushed against them and brain possibly eaten. if he survives the 1st meeting i guess he can come back with his flame thrower or sonic gun
but definatley an easier time for spidy than batman
Originally posted by lifeisaglich
Batman is knows his city well enough to even guess what he going to face each night. He doesn't get allot of powerhouses but as it has been proven before batman always as an escape plan or some device inside his suit.If batman were to switch cities to New York, then his thinking is going to change instead of just wearing he regular suites he is going to start shelling out his specialized suites. And with the stuff that batman is going to bring out (stuff that he is suppose to have) it is going to be spidy's villians who would need plot devices to get to him.
And with that said batman is going to have an easy time cleaning out spiderman's city.
Good poing. So he might take a more "Iron Man" like approach with a legion of specalized suits. Interesting...
Originally posted by brainchild81
Says the guy who said That sounds like Batman to you? Kill citizens and destroy buildings to stop Venom? Quite an imagination ya got there kid😆 Ha? Right back @ ya 😆
i was saying "ha!" to AJ's post but u posted b4 me 😠 🙄
and yes i know batman is not like that and wouldnt kill a whole bunch of people just to get one person, but what the hell, lets bend the rules a little bit and say he did, & then see what happens....
Good poing. So he might take a more "Iron Man" like approach with a legion of specalized suits. Interesting...
Exactly, but not doing the whole Iron man motif.
venom or carnage have better ninja skills as in stealth, climbing and movin from buildin to buildin. superior strength and durability. if venom webbed batman in the face, batman would suffocate and die....he has no strength to rip it off. h2h would get batman's bones crushed against them and brain possibly eaten. if he survives the 1st meeting i guess he can come back with his flame thrower or sonic gun
Yes batman would be able to pull off the web from his face thanks to the mother box.
Originally posted by lifeisaglich
Batman is knows his city well enough to even guess what he going to face each night. He doesn't get allot of powerhouses but as it has been proven before batman always as an escape plan or some device inside his suit.If batman were to switch cities to New York, then his thinking is going to change instead of just wearing he regular suites he is going to start shelling out his specialized suites. And with the stuff that batman is going to bring out (stuff that he is suppose to have) it is going to be spidy's villians who would need plot devices to get to him.
And with that said batman is going to have an easy time cleaning out spiderman's city.
When are DC writers going to make Batman having different more specialized suites? I think that it's a good idea for him to get some specialized suits even in Gotham City. Batman would be so much more powerful.
Originally posted by TheKahn
This isn't a standard fight:Assume that you live in a major city anywhere around the world with a sizable crime rate and the occasional supervillian. Who would you rather have paroling the streets, Spiderman or Bats? And why? Who woudl be the best and quickest at reducing the crime rate and keeping the streets safe?
batman simply due to his recources and backup available...
Because he could survive an encounter with Juggernaut. 🙄
Let's take a look at the Spider-Man rogues gallery:
Carnage
Green Goblin
Electro
The Kingpin (Kingpin with prep is Batman times 1000)
Kaine
Black Tarantula
Morlun
Namor (I don't give a damn what Knightfall says. Batman is bat-brunch)
Venom
Scorpion
Silver Sable
Scream
Sandman
Hydro-Man
The Life Foundation symbiotes
I'm sorry to say this, but Batman isn't as good as Spider-Man. You've got people on that list that eat tech for breakfast. What the hell is a tank gonna do against Morlun? Is a batarang going to do much against Kaine or Black Tarantula? How about Carnage, who is like Joker with an arsenal of weapons built into his skin? What about Juggernaut? I'm just gonna be honest right now. Batman has a hard time handling Slade. How the hell is he gonna handle people like Kingpin and Silvermane? Fear isn't gonna do much. These villains eat fear for breakfast. Some of Spider-Man's villains are scarier than anything that Batman has ever faced before. Batman is a great hero and all, but inferior to Spider-Man.
I don't know exactly how well Spider-man would do against Batman's rouge gallery anyway. Batman's rouge gallery usually goes by brains and have really devious plans of taking over the city. Take Joker for example, the guy is insane but he's a freaking genious who's as smart, if not smarter than Batman. That's saying a lot. Anyway, the reason Joker's plans usually don't work, is because Batman can make himself think and reason like Joker; a madman. Spider-man could never think on the level that Joker does. He has no knowledge of Joker or how he thinks. Joker's plans would simply outsmart Spidey by a lot. I doubt Spider-man would do as well against Batman's gallery because Spider-man doesn't think like he does and he usually goes by brawn. While I realize that Spider-man is very smart, he's not as smart as Batman. Anyway, because of Batman's deviously smart gallery, I don't know if he'd do a better job than the Dark Knight himself. Well, that's just my two cents.